Abstract
There are two types of pain, mechanical and non-mechanical. Mechanical pain hurts with movement/use, is not constant and is helped by morphine-type products. Non-mechanical pain is different. It is present 24 hours a day, often worse at night, and except for the pain of infection, is not relieved by morphine-type products.
If the cause of mechanical pain can be determined, it can be corrected by an operation. The usual cause of postoperative mechanical knee pain nowadays is multifactorial, i.e. a combination of minor errors, none of which on their own would require revision.
Non-mechanical pain, other than infection, is much more difficult to handle. The commonest cause is not really a pain complaint, it is disappointment due to a failure of expectation. It does not matter how often you tell patients, some patients still think they should step in a drive away. A lot of these failures of expectations become much more realistic by the end of year one.
There are several other categories. Incipient osteoarthritis or sensitive people (The Princess and the Pea). If the pain complaints were severe with minimal arthritis, an operation is not likely to help.
The patient on disability for no clear reason is unlikely to get a good result and Workmen's Compensation Board and motor vehicle accident patients are also a very bad prognostic sign and will often produce the postoperative painful knee. Preoperative use of large doses of morphine is also a very bad sign. It is not clear if it is the morphine, which influences the patient or the patient, who influences the morphine.
There are several pain syndromes, some of which are purely psychiatric such as Conversion Disorders and Somatoform Pain Disorders. Treatment of purely psychiatric conditions should be a referral to a psychiatrist is in order.
Complex regional pain syndrome is an organic pain disorder. Type 2 is causalgia or an actual nerve injury. This is unusual following knee replacement other than the odd drop foot, which even after recovery, leaves an area of dysaethesia on the dorsum of the foot. Type 1 used to be called reflex sympathetic dystrophy. This is not uncommon after total knee replacement. I managed to collect more than 40 cases. One problem is that the diagnosis to some extent is a diagnosis of exclusion. If the diagnosis can be made, then treatment is available including Cymbalta, Lyrica or Gabapentin. I have found most success with lumbar sympathetic blocks, but it is difficult to find someone, who can do these. Some patients have been treated with implantable electrical spinal stimulators with variable results.
The current flavour of the month pain syndrome is called central sensitization. The theory is that if someone has pain for more than six months, then there will be changes in the brain, which will remain after the original pain goes away, hence, the title the pain in the brain syndrome. If this theory were correct, then we as arthroplasty surgeons have been collectively wasting our time for the last 40 years as no patient would have recovered. The likelihood, therefore, of this theory having any basis in reality is pretty remote.
Fortunately, by the end of year one, the vast majority of our knee replacement patients are reasonably content with the procedure.
