Abstract
Summary
The ideal therapy for post-traumatic osteoarthritis (PTOA) must be mechanism-based and target multiple anabolic and catabolic pathways. Our results suggest an innovative combination of known pro-anabolic and anti-catabolic biologics to treat post-traumatic cartilage degeneration.
Introduction
Untreated joint injuries can result in cartilage wear and the development of PTOA. Previous studies identified the mechanisms that may govern the progression to PTOA. Here we hypothesised that targeted biologic interventions combined based on the type/time of cellular responses may constitute an effective novel treatment algorithm to arrest PTOA.
Methods
Eleven human donor normal tali, age 19–71 yo, from the Gift of Hope Organ & Tissue Donor Network were impacted using a 4mm cylindrical indenter with the impulse of 1N as discribed. 8mm cartilage explants (4mm impacted core + 4mm non-impacted adjacent ring) were removed from the joint and cultured for 14 days in 5% fetal bovine serum with or without selected biologics. Treatment groups consisted of 1) Impacted control (IC), 2) Un-impacted control (UIC); 3–5) Impaction + three combinations of BMP-7/OP-1 (100ng/ml), P188 (8 ug/ml) and tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) antagonist (100ng/ml) defined as Combo1, Combo2, and Combo3. All treatments were administered according to previously reported post-injury cellular responses. Combo1: P188 administered at day 0 for 48hrs + BMP-7 administered at day 0 for 48hrs and at days 7–14 + anti-TNF-α administered at days 0–7; Combo2: All three agents administered at day 0 for 48hrs and anti-TNF-α and BMP-7 administered again at day 7 for 48hrs; Combo3: All agents administered simultaneously at day 0 for 48hrs. Tissue and media were collected on days 0, 2, 7, and 14 and analyzed for cell viability, Safranin O staining, and proteoglycan (PG) synthesis.
Results
A single impact to articular cartilage resulted in cell death within the superficial layer of impacted region, which if untreated, expanded to the adjacent non-impacted area. It reduced cell viability by more than 2-fold (p<0.01) and triggered elevation of pro-inflammatory mediators within the first 24–48 hrs and again around day 10. Initial anabolic responses characterised by the synthesis of superficial zone protein, endogenous BMP-7 and PGs were initiated at days 5–7. Cell survival in the superficial layer was improved under the individual or combined treatments with the most pronounced sustained effect under Combo1 & 2 (∼1.5-fold increase vs IC, p<0.05). Combo1 and to a lesser extend Combo 2 markedly improved cell survival in the entire cartilage thickness, which increased from 59% in IC to 84% in Combo1, p=0.006. Both Combo1 & 2 had a stronger effect on Safranin O staining and preservation of matrix integrity than Combo 3. Contrary, Combo3 exhibited the highest effect on PG synthesis (1.8-fold increase vs IC or other two combinations; p<0.05). Combo1 & 2 were less effective.
Discussion
Current study reports two important findings: 1) the same combination of agents, but administered at various treatment regimens, can induce different effects. Prolonged administration of anti-TNF-α and BMP-7 (Combo1) had a strong effect on cell survival and matrix preservation, but was less effective in inducing chondrocyte synthetic activity suggesting that overstimulation/overdosing can have a detrimental effect on chondrocyte anabolism; 2) a window of opportunity exists to arrest cell death and delay/prevent cartilage degeneration.
