Abstract
Summary
Metal-on-metal hip replacements have been associated with adverse reactions including inflammatory pseudotumours and soft tissue necrosis. We have shown that cobalt can directly activate toll-like receptor 4, an immune receptor causing pro-inflammatory interleukin-8 secretion. This may contribute to adverse reaction development.
Introduction
Metal-on-metal hips have the highest failure rate of any joint arthroplasty material. Reasons for failure include the development of pseudotumours, soft tissue necrosis and pain around the affected joint. The adverse reactions appear to be inflammatory as failing joints are often infiltrated by immune cells such as lymphocytes. However the exact cellular and biological mechanisms underlying this inflammation are unknown. Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) is found on the surface of immune cells including macrophages and dendritic cells. It is activated by lipopolysaccharide (LPS) from Gram negative bacteria, inducing an immune response against the pathogen through increased secretion of pro-inflammatory cytokines. It has recently been shown that nickel can activate TLR4, causing inflammation. Cobalt, a component of many metal-on-metal joints, is adjacent to nickel in the periodic table and shares a number of nickel's properties. Consequently we hypothesised that cobalt ions from metal-on-metal joints can activate TLR4.
Methods
An in vitro cell culture model was developed using human and murine TLR4 reporter cell lines to investigate the effects of metal ions, including cobalt, on TLR4. Real-time PCR was used to examine the effect of cobalt on inflammatory gene expression, including IL-8, CCL-2 and IRAK-2, while an ELISA assay was conducted to investigate IL-8 protein expression in a human macrophage cell line (MonoMac 6). The TLR4 agonist LPS was included as a positive control and as a negative control TLR4 activation was blocked using the chemical agonist CLI-095 (Invivogen, UK).
Results
Using human TLR4 reporter cells we show that cobalt at clinically-relevant concentrations can activate human TLR4. This effect appears unique to humans as murine TLR4 is unresponsive to cobalt but still responds to LPS. We also demonstrate that in human macrophages physiologically-relevant concentrations of cobalt cause increased pro-inflammatory IL-8 secretion (p<0.001). IL-8 is involved in perpetuating the immune response by recruiting more inflammatory cells to the site of inflammation. Cobalt-induced IL-8 secretion can be blocked using a TLR4 antagonist (p<0.001) showing that the effect is due to cobalt activation. Cobalt ions also alter gene expression in human macrophages. Cobalt upregulates expression of IL-8 and IRAK2 genes; IRAK2 is a key component of the TLR4 signalling pathway. Interestingly, cobalt causes downregulation of the CCL2 gene whereas it is upregulated in response to LPS.
Discussion
In this study we have demonstrated that cobalt ions can activate human TLR4 signalling and in human macrophages this can increase expression of pro-inflammatory IL-8. We have also developed a robust series of assays for determining the effects of metal ions and other orthopaedic materials on the TLR4 signalling pathway. These methods will be used to investigate the immunological effects of additional orthopaedic metals (e.g. chromium, titanium and molybdenum). This work has identified a key pathway involved in the immune response to metal ions which can now be investigated for genetic variability and as a potential therapeutic target.
