Abstract
Summary Statement
In young, active patients cementless THR demonstrates excellent prosthetic stability by RSA and outstanding clinical outcomes at 5 years using a tapered titanium femoral stem, crosslinked polyethylene liners and either titanium or tantalum shells.
Introduction
Early femoral implant stability is essential to long-term success in total hip replacement. Radiostereometric analysis (RSA) provides precise measurements of micromotion of the stem relative to the femur that are otherwise not detectable by routine radiographs. This study characterised micromotion of a tapered, cementless femoral stem and tantalum porous-coated vs. titanium acetabular shells in combination with highly cross-linked UHMWPE or conventional polyethylene liners using radiostereometric analysis (RSA) for 5 years following THR.
Patients and Methods
This IRB-approved, prospective, double randomised, blinded study, involved 46 patients receiving a primary THR by a single surgeon. Each patient was randomised to receive a titanium (23) (Trilogy, Zimmer) or tantalum (23) (Modular Tantalum shell, Zimmer) uncemented hemispheric shell and either a highly-crosslinked or conventional polyethylene liner. Tantalum RSA markers were implanted in each patient. All patients had a Dorr A or B femoral canal and received a cementless, porous-coated titanium tapered stem (M/L Taper, Zimmer). All final femoral broaches were stable to rotational and longitudinal stress. RSA examinations, Harris Hip, UCLA, WOMAC, SF-12 scores were obtained at 10 days, 6 months, and annually through 5 years.
Results
All patients demonstrated statistically significant improvement in Harris Hip, WOMAC, and SF-12 PCS scores post-operatively. Evaluation of polyethylene wear demonstrated that median penetration measurements were significantly greater in the conventional compared to the HXPLE liner cohorts at 1 year through 5 years follow-up (p<0.003). At 5 years, conventional liners showed 0.38 ± 0.05mm vertical wear whereas HXLPE liners showed 0.08 ± 0.02mm (p<0.003). Evaluation of the femoral stems demonstrated that the rate of subsidence was highest in the first 6 months (0.09mm/yr), with no other detectable motion through 5 years. Two outlying patients had significantly higher stem subsidence values at 6 months (0.7 mm and 1.0mm). One stem stabilised without further subsidence after 6 months (0.7mm), and the other stem stabilised at 1 year (1.5mm). Neither patient has clinical evidence of loosening. Evaluation of acetabular shells demonstrated less median vertical translation in tantalum than titanium shells at each time-point except at 3-years follow-up, however due to large standard errors, there was no significant difference between the two designs (p>0.05). These large standard errors were predominantly caused by two outliers, neither of which had clinical evidence of loosening.
Discussion/Conclusion
In this RSA study of young THR patients, cementless tapered femoral stems, highly crosslinked polyethylene liners, and tantalum or titanium acetabular shells all demonstrated excellent performance through 5 years follow-up. Highly crosslinked polyethylene liners demonstrated significantly less wear than conventional liners. The femoral stem showed excellent stability through 5 years, with no clinical or radiologic episodes of failure. The small amount of micromotion seen is less than that previously reported for similar tapered, cementless stems and approaches the accuracy of RSA (0.05mm). Both acetabular shells demonstrated excellent stability with minimal micromotion at 5 years without significant differences in migration. All patients demonstrated significant clinical improvement in pain and function and additional RSA evaluation of these patients is planned.
