Abstract
Introduction
Despite the high regenerative capacity of bone, large bone defects often require treatment involving bone grafts. Conventional autografting and allografting treatments have disadvantages, such as donor site morbidity, immunogenicity and lack of donor material. Bone tissue engineering offers the potential to achieve major advances in the development of alternative bone grafts by exploiting the bone-forming capacity of osteoblastic cells. However, viable cell culture models are essential to investigate osteoblast behavior. Three-dimensional (3D) cell culture systems have become increasingly popular because biological relevance of 3D cultures may exceed that of cell monolayers (2D) grown in standard tissue culture. However, only few direct comparisons between 2D and 3D models have been published. Therefore, we performed a pilot study comparing 2D and 3D culture models of primary human osteoblasts with regard to expression of transcription factors RUNX2 and osterix as well as osteogenic differentiation.
Patients and Methods
Primary human osteoblasts were extracted from femoral neck spongy bone obtained during surgery procedures. Primary human osteoblasts of three donor patients were cultured in monolayers and in three different 3D culture models: 1) scaffold-free cultures, also referred to as histoids, which form autonomously after multilayer release of an osteoblast culture; 2) short-term (10-day) collagen scaffolds seeded with primary human osteoblasts (HOB); 3) long-term (29-day) collagen scaffolds seeded with HOB. Expression levels of transcription factors RUNX2 and osterix, both involved in osteoblast differentiation, were investigated using quantitative PCR and immunohistochemical staining. Furthermore, markers of osteogenic differentiation were evaluated, such as alkaline phosphatase activity, osteocalcin expression, and mineral deposition, as well as the expression of collagen type I and fibronectin extracellular matrix proteins.
Results
Cells of the same origin, which were cultivated in different culture models, showed varying expression levels with regard to transcription factors RUNX2 and osterix as well as osteogenic markers. Increased levels of transcription factor RUNX2 and the extracellular matrix protein fibronectin were observed in all 3D cell culture models compared to monolayers. Furthermore, long-term cultivated histoids showed increased levels of osteogenic late-stage marker osteocalcin and transcription factor osterix. Additionally, long-term collagen scaffolds seeded with HOB showed elevated levels of osteocalcin compared to monolayers and short-term scaffolds. Moreover, alkaline phosphatase activity and mineralization capacity were increased in histoids.
Conclusion
Considering the complex biochemical interactions of cells with surrounding cells and the extracellular matrix in vivo, important biological properties are disregarded when cells are only studied in 2D study models. Hence, we compared different 3D HOB cell culture models to 2D HOB monolayers with regard to expression of transcription factors RUNX2 and osterix as well as osteogenic differentiation in vitro. Our pilot study indicated that three-dimensional study models may promote osteogenic differentiation in vitro. Additionally, a beneficial effect of longer culture duration on osteogenic differentiation was observed. Hence, our findings emphasise the importance of dimension and culture duration when studying osteoblast function. Subsequent studies with higher sample sized may lead to the development of viable primary human osteoblast cell culture models for bone tissue engineering.
Summary
Three-dimensional cell culture models of primary human osteoblasts (HOB), including collagen scaffolds and scaffold-free cultures, were compared to HOB monolayers with regard to osteogenic differentiation. Our study indicated that three-dimensional study models may promote osteogenic differentiation of HOB in vitro.
