Abstract
Summary Statement
Pincer deformities are involved in the genesis of femoro-acetabular impingement (FAI). Radiographic patterns suggestive of pincer deformities are common among general population. Prevalence of the pincer deformities among general population may be overestimated if only plain radiographs are considered.
Background
Pincer deformities (coxa profunda, protrusio acetabuli, global retroversion, isolated cranial over-coverage) have been advocated as a cause of femoro-acetabular impingement (FAI) and early hip osteoarthritis (OA). Different radiographic patterns may advocate the presence of a pincer deformity. The prevalence of these radiographic patterns among general adult population, as their role in early hip OA, is poorly defined.
Methods
From a database of 40.351 pelvic radiograms and CT collected at our institution between 2005 and 2010, we selected 118 caucasian individuals (56 females, 62 males), aged between 15 and 60 years, who underwent both plain radiographs and CT of the pelvis. A series of exclusion criteria were strictly applied to achieve a sample of adult general population as more representative as possible. In particular patients with presence of any disease involving hip joint, including: advanced hip OA (grade II or III of Tonnis scale), head necrosis, fractures, heterotopic ossifications, bone and soft tissue tumors, rheumatic pathologies, classic hip dysplasia with lateral center-edge angle (L-CEA) less than 20°, clinical diagnosis of FAI or hip pain, were excluded from the present study. We also excluded patients in which open growth plates, osteopenia, hardware or evidence of prior surgery were present. Radiographs were investigated for pelvic tilt, signs of retroversion, lateral center-edge angle (L-CEA), presence of coxa profunda or protrusio acetabuli. EAV was measured on CT scans at the equatorial plane of the acetabulum passing by the 3 o'clock position, while CAV was calculated at a more cranial level corresponding to the 1 o'clock position EAV and CAV were obtained in the axial plane by measuring the angle made by a line connecting the anterior and posterior rims of the acetabulum and a line perpendicular to the line connecting the ischial spines. A new parameter, Acetabular torsion (AT), has been introduced in order to discriminate between global retroversion and isolated cranial over-coverage. AT was defined as the difference between EAV and CAV. Cam deformity was assessed by calculating the alpha angle on the femoral side; an alpha angle > 55° was considered abnormal and suggestive of cam deformity. Radiological signs of chondrolabral degeneration were noticed.
Results
Mean EAV and mean CAV were higher in females, mean AA was higher in males. L-CEA, EAV and CAV increased with age. Mean AT was 8.8±6.3. AT was inversely related to CAV (r=−0.799; p<0.0005) but independent from EAV (r=−0.076; p=0.244). EAV≤10.2° was defined as the marker of global retroversion, while AT≥21.2° was defined as the marker of isolated cranial over-coverage. Overall prevalence of pincer deformities was 21.6% (> females; p=0.02). Early OA changes were related to age (p<0.0005) and AA (p<0.0005), but not to pincer deformities (p=0.96). Radiological signs of retroversion showed good or excellent negative predictability but poor positive predictability.
Conclusions
Radiographic patterns of pincer deformities are common among general population. Relationship with radiological signs of chondrolabral degeneration is poor. CT allows to discriminate between global retroversion and isolated cranial over-coverage. Prevalence of the pincer deformities among general population may be overestimated if only plain radiographs are considered.
