Abstract
Summary
Particulate wear debris with different chemical composition induced similar periprosthetic tissue reactions in patients with loosened uncemented and cemented titanium hip implants, which suggests that osteolysis can develop independent of particle composition.
Introduction
Periprosthetic osteolysis is a serious long-term complication in total hip replacements (THR). Wear debris-induced inflammation is thought to be the main cause for periprosthetic bone loss and implant loosening. The aim of the present study was to compare the tissue reactions and wear debris characteristics in periprosthetic tissues from patients with failed uncemented (UC) and cemented (C) titanium alloy hip prostheses. We hypothesised that implant wear products around two different hip designs induced periprosthetic inflammation leading to osteolysis.
Patients & Methods
Thirty THR-patients undergoing revision surgery were included: Fifteen patients had loose cemented titanium stems (Titan®, DePuy) and 15 had well-fixed uncemented titanium stems (Profile, DePuy), but loose or worn uncemented metal-backed cups with conventional UHMWPE liners (Gemini, Tropic and Tri-Lock Plus, DePuy; Harris/Galante and Trilogy, Zimmer). A semi-quantitative histological evaluation was performed in 59 sections of periprosthetic tissues using light microscopy. Wear particles were counted by polarised light and high resolution dark-field microscopy. Additionally, particle composition was determined by SEM-EDXA following particle isolation using an enzymatic digestion method. Blood metal ions were determined with high resolution-ICP-MS.
Results
The implants in the uncemented group were revised after a median of 15.7 years (range: 7.25–19.3) due to osteolysis and high wear of the polyethylene liner and metal backing resulting in gross metallosis, and/or cup loosening. The average lifetime of implants in the cemented group was only 6.5 years (range: 1.5–11.75) due to early stem loosening with large osteolysis pockets in the femur close to the cement mantle. Tissue examination revealed similar results for both groups: numerous mononuclear histiocytes and chronic inflammatory cells, a few neutrophils and multinucleated giant cells, and to some extent necrosis. The amount of metal particles per histiocyte positively correlated with the tissue reactions in the cemented, but not in the uncemented group. A higher particle load (medians: C: 14727 vs. UC: 1382 particles/mm2, p<0.0001) was found in tissues adjacent to cemented stems, which contained mainly submicron ZrO2 particles. Particles containing pure Ti or Ti alloy elements (size range: 0.21 to 6.46 µm) were most abundant in tissues from the uncemented group. Here, also PE was more frequent, but accounted only for a small portion of total particles (2.8 PE/mm2). The blood concentrations of titanium (range: 3.8–138.5 microgram/L) and zirconium (cemented cases, range: 0.6–3.5 microgram/L) were highly elevated in cases with high abrasive wear and metallosis.
Discussion/Conclusion
Phagocytosis of different wear particles by histiocytes induced a similar chronic inflammatory reaction in the periprosthetic tissues in both groups. ZrO2 particles, originating from bone cement degradation, dominated in the cemented group, while in the uncemented group the high abundance of pure Ti and Ti alloy particles of various sizes indicates wear of the metal-backed cups. The low density of polyethylene particles in the tissues suggests that they are not solely responsible for the tissue reactions and accompanying osteolysis. Our findings suggest that the chemical composition of wear particles plays a minor role in the mechanism of osteolysis. Particle size, load and ionic exposure might be more important.
