Abstract
The internal fixation of scaphoid bone fractures remains technically difficult due to the size of the bone and its three- dimensional shape. Early rigid fixation, e.g with a screw, has been shown to support good functional outcome. In terms of stability of the fracture, biomechanical studies have shown a superior result with central screw placement in the scaphoid in comparison with an eccentric position, which can lead to delayed or non-union. Image-based navigation could be helpful for these cases. The main limitation of reference-based navigation systems is their dependence on fixed markers like used in modern navigation systems. Therefore it is limited in treatment of small bone fractures. In former experimental studies 20 artificial hand specimens were randomised into two groups and blinded with polyurethane foam: 10 were treated conventionally and 10 were image guided. For trajectory guidance a reduction of duration of surgery, radiation exposure and perforation rate compared to the conventional technique could be found. Accuracy was not improved by the new technique. The purpose of this study was to identify the possible advantages of the new guidance technique in a clinical setting.
In this prospective, non-randomised case series we tested the feasibility of the system into the accommodated surgical workflow. There was no control group. Three cases of scaphoid fractures were included. All of the patients were treated with a cannulated screw following K-wire placement via the percutaneous volar approach described. In addition, length measurements and screw sizes were determined using special features of the system. The performing surgeon and two attending assistant doctors (one assisting the surgical procedure, one handling the guidance system) had to rate the system following each procedure via a user questionnaire. They had to rate the system's integration in the workflow and its contribution to the success of the surgical procedure in percentages (0 %: totally unsuccessful; 100 %: perfect integration and excellent contribution). All of the clinical procedures were performed by the same surgeon.
The surgeons rated the system's contribution and integration as very good (91 and 94 % of 100 %). No adverse event occurred. An average of 1.3 trials ± 0.6 (1; 2) was required to place the K-wire in the fractured scaphoid bone. The dose-area product was 19 cGycm2 ± 3 (16; 22). The mean incision until suture time was 36.7 min ± 5.7 (30; 40). For clinical cases, the system was integrated and rated as very helpful by users.
The system is simple and can be easily integrated into the surgical workflow. Therefore it should be evaluated further in prospective clinical series.
