Abstract
Introduction
Regarding TKA, patient specific cutting guides (PSCG), which have the same fitting surface with patient's bones or cartilages and uniquely specify the resection plane by fitting guides with bones, have been developed to assist easy, low cost and accurate surgery. They have already been used clinically in Europe and the USA. However little has been reported on clinical positioning accuracy of PSCG. Generally, the methods of making PSCG can be divided into 3 methods; construct 3D bone models with Magnetic Resonance (MR) images, construct 3D bone models with Computed Tomography (CT) images, and the last is to construct 3D bone models with both MR and CT images. In the present study, PSCG were made based on 3D bone models with CT images, examined the positioning accuracy with fresh-frozen cadavers.
Materials and Methods
Two fresh-frozen cadavers with four knees were scanned by CT. Image processing software for 3D design (Mimics Ver. 14, Marialise Inc.) was used to construct 3D bone model by image thresholding. We designed femoral cutting guides and tibial cutting guides by CAD software (NX 5.0, Siemens PLM Software Co.). CT free navigation system (VectorVision Knee, BrainLab, Inc.) was used to measure positioning error. Average absolute value of positioning error for each PSCG was derived.
Results
The average absolute value of positioning error in femoral PSCG was 1.5±0.8° for varus/valgus, 2.3±1.9° for extension/flexion, 1.2±1.8 mm for bone resection. The stability of femoral PSCG was satisfactory. The average absolute value of positioning error in tibial PSCG was 4.3±2.5° for varus/valgus, 5.2±3.3° for anterior slope/posterior slope, 2.6±1.1 mm for bone resection. The stability of tibial PSCG was not sufficient.
Discussion
PSCG of the present study were made based on CT images, mainly designed to be fit with cortex, keeping away from cartilage or osteophytes. The fitting surfaces of distal femoral PSCG covered anterior femoral cortex. Also, the fitting surface of tibial PSCG fit to anterior medial cortex of horizontal tibial tuberosity. The average absolute value of positioning error by tibial PSCG varied widely. The main cause for this was their contacts with patellar tendon. Lateral sides of PSCG were contacted with patella tendon near the tibial tuberosity, they were pushed medially. Positioning accuracy of the femoral PSCG is thought to be enough for clinical application.
