Abstract
Aim
Our aim was to compare the Wilkins'-modified Gartland classification and AO classifications of supracondylar humeral fracture with respect to: -Inter-observer reliability; Association of fracture-grade with radiological quality of reduction; Association of fracture-grade with complications.
Methods
The unit database was interrogated to identify all operated supracondylar fractures between 2007–2011. Radiographs from each case were evaluated by four observers (three consultants, one trainee) and classified according to Gartland and the AO system. Inter-observer reliability was calculated using Cohen's Kappa coefficient. Radiological quality of reduction was evaluated using a new scoring system, combining the anterior humeral line, the lateral capitello-humeral angle (LCHA) and Baumann's angle, (compared to reference values). Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed to determine whether there was a statistically significant difference in scores between the fracture grades. Case notes were reviewed for pre- and post-operative complication, and chi-squared test performed to compare the incidence between different fracture grades.
Results
83 cases were identified for fracture classification and 66 for assessment of reduction and complications. Inter-observer reliability was 0.58 for Gartland (moderate agreement), and 0.70 for the AO classification (good agreement). ANOVA demonstrated no significant difference in the overall reduction scores between the different grades of either classification. Mean scores for LCHA were lower for Gartland-2b (p=0.02) and AO-3 (p=0.007) groups (compared to Gartland-3 and AO-4). Complications were more frequent with the higher grades of fracture in both classifications (p<0.05).
Conclusion
The AO classification has greater reliability and should be considered as an alternative to the Gartland classification. A higher grade of fracture is not associated with inferior radiographic outcomes. Surgeons should be aware that restoration of the LCHA is more difficult with the Gartland-2b and AO-3 fractures, probably because of the intact posterior cortex. A greater rate of complications should be expected with higher grades of fracture.
