Abstract
Purpose
Twelve case reports of distal femur fractures as post-operative complications after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction have been described in the literature. The femoral tunnel has been suggested as a potential stress riser for fracture formation. The recent increase in double bundle ACL reconstructions may compound this risk. This is the first biomechanical study to examine the stress riser effect of the femoral tunnel(s) after ACL reconstruction. The hypotheses tested in this study are that the femoral tunnel acts as a stress riser to fracture and that this effect increases with the size of the tunnel (8mm versus 10mm) and with the number of tunnels (one versus two).
Method
Femoral tunnels simulating single bundle (SB) hamstring graft (8 mm), bone-patellar tendon-bone graft (10 mm), and double bundle (DB) ACL reconstruction (7mm, 6 mm) were drilled in fourth generation saw bones. These three experimental groups and a control group consisting of native saw bones without tunnels, were loaded to failure.
Result
All fractures occurred through the tunnels in the double tunnel group whereas fractures did not consistently occur through the tunnels in the single tunnel groups. The mean fracture load was 6145 N 471 N in the native group, 5691 N 198 N in the 8 mm single tunnel group, 5702 N 282 N in the 10 mm single tunnel group, and 4744 N 418 N in the double tunnel group. The mean fracture load for the double tunnel group was significantly different when compared to native, 8 mm single bundle, and 10 mm single bundle groups independently (p value = 0.0016, 0.0060, and 0.0038 respectively). No other statistically significant differences were identified.
Conclusion
An anatomically placed femoral tunnel in single bundle ACL reconstruction in our experimental model was not a stress riser to fracture, whereas the two femoral tunnels in double bundle ACL reconstruction significantly decreased load to failure. The results support the sparcity of reported peri-ACL reconstruction femur fractures in single femoral tunnel techniques. However, the increased fracture risk in double bundle ACL reconstruction is a cause for concern and may impact patient selection.
