Abstract
Intra-articular screw fixation is indicated for internal fixation of large osteochondral fragments secondary to trauma or osteochondritis dissecans. During surgery, orthopaedic drills are used to prepare a hole through which the screw can pass. Previous work has shown that mechanical injury to articular cartilage results in a zone of cell death adjacent to the traumatised articular cartilage (1). Here, we characterise and quantify the margin of in situ chondrocyte death surrounding drill holes and screws (standard cortical and headless compression designs) placed in mature bovine articular cartilage to model the orthopaedic procedure.
Drill holes (1mm) were made through the articular cartilage and bone of intact bovine metacarpophalangeal joints obtained from 3-yr old cows within 12hrs of slaughter. Osteochondral explants (∼1cm square and 2-3mm thick) encompassing the drilled holes in articular cartilage and subchondral bone were harvested using a chisel. Explants were then incubated in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium for 45mins with CMFDA (5-chloromethylfluorescein diacetate) and PI (propidium iodide; both at 10micromolar) to identify/quantify living and dead in situ chondrocytes respectively in a consecutive series of axial optical sections using confocal scanning laser microscopy (CLSM).
The drill holes through cartilage appeared to have clearly defined edges with no macroscopic evidence of cartilage splitting. However visualisation of fluorescently-labelled in situ chondrocytes by CLSM demonstrated clear cell death around the periphery of the drilled hole which was 166±19 micrometers in width. This increased with a larger diameter (1.5mm) drill to 450±151 micrometers (all data are means±s.e.m.; n=3). Preliminary experiments indicated that the margin of chondrocyte death around a 1.5mm hole was dramatically increased further by the insertion of screws into pre-drilled holes.
These results suggest that the mechanical trauma associated with cartilage drilling and the insertion of intra-articular screws occurs with marked death of in situ chondrocytes extending into normal cartilage beyond the area occupied by the screw. As chondrocytes are not replaced in mature cartilage, their loss around the hole/screw will mean that the extracellular matrix is not maintained, inevitably leading to cartilage failure.
