Abstract
Computer navigation has been advocated as a means to improve limb and component alignment and reduce the number of outliers after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). We aimed to determine the alignment outcomes of 1500 consecutive computer-assisted TKAs performed by a single surgeon, using the same implant, with a minimum 1 year follow-up, and to analyze the outliers. Based on radiographic analysis, 112 limbs (7.5%) in 109 patients with mechanical axis malalignment of > 3° were identified and analyzed.
The indication for TKA was osteoarthritis in 107 patients and rheumatoid arthritis in 2 patients. Fifty-eight patients (53%) had undergone simultaneous bilateral TKA and 13 patients (12%) had a BMI >30. Preoperative varus deformity was seen in 100 limbs and valgus deformity in 12 limbs. Thirty limbs (27%) had an extra-articular deformity (2 post HTO limbs, 3 malunited fractures, 1 stress fracture, 21 severe femoral bowing and 3 tibial bowing) and 21 limbs (19%) had severe lateral laxity or subluxation. Thirty-eight limbs (34%) had a preoperative deformity of =10° and 24 limbs (21.5%) had varus or valgus deformity of >20°.
Postoperatively, 11 limbs were malaligned at ±3°, 74 limbs at ±4°, 22 limbs at ±5°, 2 limbs at ±6°, and 2 limbs at ±7°. Coronal plane malalignment of > ±3° of the femoral component was seen in 28 limbs, tibial component in 32 limbs, and both femoral and tibial components in 13 limbs. Twenty-six limbs with preoperative varus deformity had a postoperative valgus alignment of >183° and 3 limbs with valgus deformity had a postoperative varus alignment of <177°.
The incidence of outliers for postoperative limb alignment was low at 7.5% with the tibial component showing a higher incidence of coronal malalignment. Malalignment may be more common in cases of simultaneous bilateral procedures, preoperative limb alignment of =10°, limbs with extra-articular deformities and severe lateral instability. There was a tendency towards over-correction of the hip-knee-ankle axis in both varus- and valgus-deformed knees. Further detailed statistical analysis of the data will be presented.
This is the largest single-surgeon series of consecutive navigated TKAs and consequently the largest analysis of outliers that highlights which knees are likely to fall outside the +3 degrees of acceptable alignment and which therefore behoove the surgeon to exercise greater caution.