Abstract
We designed this study to determine the clinical evidence to support use of the five degree tibial extra-medullary cutting block over the zero degree cutting block.
We identified three groups of patients from the databases and clinical notes at St Michaels Hospital, Toronto. Group one were primary total knees performed using the five degree cutting block, group two were primary total knees performed using the zero degree cutting block and the third group were computer navigated primary total knees. Patients in all three groups were age and sex matched. The senior author advocating use of the five degree block aimed to obtain a five degree posterior slope. The senior author who advocated the use of computer navigation, or the traditional zero degree cutting block, aimed to obtain a three degree posterior slope. All operations were performed by residents or clinical fellows, under the supervision of the senior authors. Patient radiographs were assessed to obtain the optimal direct lateral view obtained and they were saved on a database. Two independent blinded researchers assessed the posterior slope using Siemens Magicweb Software Version VA42C_0206. Two methods were used and the results averaged. The average posterior slope for the navigated total knee replacements was 0.1 degrees (−2 to 4). The average posterior slope for the five degree cutting block was 5.2 degrees (−2 to 16). The average posterior slope for the zero degree block was 3.79 degrees (−2 to 13). Computer navigated knee arthroplasty patients had significantly less variation in outlier measurements compared to the traditionally jigged arthroplasty patients. They were however, less accurate. The five degree cutting block tended to provide a more consistent posterior slope angle, but both the five degree and zero degree cutting blocks had variability in outliers. Computer Navigated Total Knee replacement provides a more consistent and reproducible tibial cut with less variability in alignment than extra-medullary jigs. The traditional five degree cutting block tended to provide a more reliable five degree posterior slope than the zero degree block, but was still subject to outliers.
