Abstract
Femoroacetabular impingement is a condition in which the femoral head/neck region abnormally contacts the acetabulum, limiting the range of motion of the hip and often associated with pain, damage, and loss of function. The pathophysiology of osteoarthritic changes stemming from impingement syndromes has been linked to the shape of the hip; however, little is known about the influence of the soft tissues to this process.
In this pilot study, we used computer-assisted navigation technology to track motion on a cadaver that had mild bilateral cam-impingement lesions, and then performed a virtual simulation to locate sites of impingement. We hypothesised that soft tissues contribute to the degree and location of impingement, so we compared impingements across three different dissection states: (i) all soft tissues intact; (ii) post-capsulectomy; with only the labrum and ligamentum teres remaining; and (iii) disarticulated, with labrum and ligamentum teres removed.
With ethical approval, we used one fresh frozen cadaver pelvis that was sectioned above the fifth lumbar vertebra and at the knee. The femurs and pelvis were implanted with fiducial screws as an accurate means for surface-based image registration. With all soft tissues intact, tissues were imaged using computed tomography with a slice thickness of 0.625 mm. The CT scans were imported into Mimics (v13.0, Materialise, Belgium) and carefully segmented, with particular detail to the articular regions and fiducials, to create 3D digital models of the pelvis and femurs.
On each side, optical local coordinate reference (LCR) bodies were attached at the proximal femur and iliac crest to permit spatial tracking with an Optotrak Certus camera (Northern Digital Inc., Waterloo, Canada). The 3D digital models were imported into the VSS navigation system (iGO Technologies, Kingston, Canada) and scrupulously registered to the anatomy using the fiducial screws and a calibrated probe. The pose of the femur and pelvis were recorded throughout a series of twelve movements involving various combinations of flexion-extension, abduction-adduction, internal-external rotation and circumduction, as well as functional movements typical of a clinical hip screening. Soft tissues were selectively removed and the movements were repeated post-capsulectomy and completely disarticulated.
The recorded pose data were applied to the 3D digital models to perform a computational simulation of the movements during the trials. The pose data were expressed in coordinates of the anterior pelvic plane to compute angles of motion in the principal directions (flexion, abduction, rotation). The motion data were further filtered so that only comparable ranges of motion were present for data analysis. Algorithms were developed to determine bone-on-bone impingement locations by finding contact points between the models.
Impingement locations were plotted on the digital models of the femur and pelvis in order to establish zones of impingement. The surface area of each impingement zone was computed by using a Crust-based algorithm that triangulated impingement points encompassing a region, and then summed the surface area of each triangle to estimate the total impingement surface area.
Upon visual inspection, it was immediately apparent that impingements tended to occur in well-defined regions. On the femur, these were found along aspects of the head-neck junction, especially on or near osteophytes. On the pelvis, impingement regions were found along the acetabular rim and extending into the lunate region.
With soft tissues intact, both femurs and pelvis had prominent anterior and posterior impingement zones. In contrast, post-capsulectomy impingement zones were predominately confined to the anterior region. It should be noted, however, that the total impingement area decreased post-capsulectomy, representing only about 25% of the total area of impingements when all soft tissues were intact. This was also true in the disarticulated state.
Both femurs had mild posterior cam lesions, the right worse than the left. Impingements were seen at these sites with soft tissues intact, but diminished almost entirely post-capsulectomy. The anterior lesions were located contra coup to these cam lesions.
With soft tissues intact, impingements tended to occur in external rotation and abduction. With soft tissues removed there was a pronounced shift towards impingements occurring in internal rotation. Impingements were also noted in large flexion angles and large abduction-adduction angles in the absence of soft tissues.
Although it is widely accepted that the hip is spherical in shape and has ball-and-socket kinematics, recent work suggests that the osteoarthritic hip is aspherical and that translational motion is present. On a very limited series, this work is supportive of the latter observation: if hip motion is purely spherical, a decrease in impingements post-capsulectomy is exceedingly hard to describe. However, if soft tissues cause translatory motion, then their absence logically should lead to a change in the impingement pattern (which we found).
This preliminary study provides a methodology for studying the effects of soft tissue on impingements. We conclude that soft tissues do indeed play an important role in impingement and may even contribute to the development of impingement lesions. Limitations include a small sample size, so further studies are required prior to conclusively establishing impingement patterns in passive kinematics of cadaver hips.
