Abstract
Recently, axial radiography has received attention for the assessment of distal femur rotational alignment, and satisfactory results have been as compared with the CT method. The purpose of this study was to assess rotational alignment of the femoral component in knee flexion by axial radiography and to compare flexion stabilities achieved by navigational and robotic total knee arthroplasty (TKA). In addition, the authors also evaluated the effects of flexion stability on functional outcomes in these two groups.
Sixty-four patients that underwent TKA for knee osteoarthritis with a minimum of follow-up of 1 year constituted the study cohort. Patients in the navigational group (N = 32) underwent TKA using the gap balancing technique and patients in the robotic group (N = 32) underwent TKA using the measured resection technique. To assess flexion stability using axial radiography a novel technique designed by the authors was used. Rotations of femoral components and mediolateral gaps in the neutral position on flexion radiographs was measured and compared. Valgus and varus stabilities under valgus-varus stress loading, and total flexion stabilities (defined as the sum of valgus and varus stability) were also compared, as were clinical outcomes at final follow up visits.
A significant difference was found between the navigation and robotic groups for mean external rotation of the femoral component (2.1° and 0.4°, respectively; p = 0.003). Mean mediolateral gap in neutral at 90° flexion position was 0.17° in the navigation group and 0.07° in the robotic group (p = 0.126), and mean total stability was 7.82° in the robotic group and 8.10° in the navigation group (p = 0.35). Clinically, no significant intergroup difference was found in terms of ranges of motion, HSS scores, KS scores, or WOMAC scores.
Both navigational and robotic techniques provide excellent clinical and flexion stability results. Furthermore, axial radiography was found to provide a useful, straightforward means of detecting rotational alignment, flexion gaps, and flexion stability.
