Abstract
Open cheilectomy is an established surgical treatment for hallux rigidus. Cheilectomy is now being performed using minimally invasive(MIS) techniques. In this prospective study we report the outcome of minimally invasive cheilectomy comparing the results with a matched group who had cheilectomy using standard open procedure.
Prospective study of 47 patients. 22 patients had MIS cheilectomy between March 2009 and September 2010. We compared the outcome with a matched group (25 patients) who had open cheilectomy. Functional outcome was assessed using the Manchester Oxford Foot and ankle questionnaire (MOXFQ). The MOXFQ is a validated 16-item, patient-generated questionnaire designed to be self-completed and used as an outcome measure for foot surgery. It comprises three domains foot pain, walking and standing problems and social interaction. Total score ranges from 0 (best score) to 64 (worst score). Patients completed preoperative and postoperative questionnaires. Patients’ satisfaction and complications were recorded.
In the MIS group, the median follow up was 11 months (4–23. The median preoperative MOXFQ score was 34/64(23) and the median postoperative score was 19/64 (p value <0.02) In the open group the median follow up was 17 months (9–27). The median preoperative MOXFQ score was 35/64 and the median postoperative score was 7.5/64 and this difference was statistically significant (<0.0001). There were three failures in the open group (Fusion) compared to none in the MIS.
MIS cheilectomy is an effective alternative procedure with satisfactory functional outcome and high patient satisfaction. Results are comparable to the standard open cheilectomy with a lower apparent failure rate. The results of our randomised controlled trial comparing MIS cheilectomy to open cheilectomy are awaited.
