Abstract
Introduction
Preoperative planning is an essential procedure for successful total hip arthroplasty. Many studies reported lower accuracy of two-dimensional analogue or digital templating for developmentally dysplastic hips (DDH). There have been few studies regarding the utility of three-dimensional (3D) templating for DDH. The aim of the present study is to assess the accuracy and reliability of 3D templating of cementless THA for hip dysplasia.
Methods
We used 86 sets of 3D-CT data of 84 patients who underwent consecutive cementless THA using an anatomical stem and a rim-enlarged cup. There were six men and 78 women with the mean age of 58 years. The diagnosis was developmental dysplasia in 70 hips and osteonecrosis in 14 hips and primary osteoarthritis in 2 hips. There were 53 hips in Crowe group I, 11 hips in Crowe group II and 6 hips in Crowe group III. Each operator performed 3D templating prior surgery using a planning workstation of CT-based navigation system. Planned-versus-achieved accuracy was evaluated. The templating results were categorized as either exact size or +/− 1 size of implanted size. To assess the intra- and inter-planner reliabilities, 3D templating was performed by two authors blinded to surgery twice at an interval of one month. Kappa values were calculated. The accuracy and the intra- and inter-planner reliabilities were compared between the DDH group (70 hips) and the non DDH group (16 hips).
Results
There was no significant difference in accuracy of component sizes between the DDH group and the non-DDH group. The accuracy of templating for cup sizes was 76 % for DDH and 75 % for non-DDH group (p=0.95). If accuracy was expanded to include all cups within one size of the implanted size, the accuracy was 97 % and 94 %, respectively (p=0.51). The accuracy of templating for stem sizes was 60 % for the DDH group and 75 % for the non-DDH group (p=0.27). The accuracy within 1 size was 99 % and 94 %, respectively (p=0.25). Regarding intra-planner reliability, mean kappa value for the cup size was 0.67 in the DDH group and 0.81 for the non-DDH group (p=0.18). Mean kappa value for the stem size was 0.64 in the DDH group and 0.79 for the non-DDH group (p=0.18). There were no significant differences in intra-planner reliability between the DDH and non-DDH group. Regarding inter-planner reliability for the cup size, mean kappa value was 0.33 in the DDH group and 0.37 in the non-DDH group (p=0.14). Mean kappa value for the stem size was 0.46 in the DDH group and 0.69 in the non-DDH group (p=0.07). There were no significant differences in inter-planner reliability between the DDH and non-DDH group.
Conclusion
The 3D templating for cementless THA was accurate for hip dysplasia. Intra- and inter-planner reliabilities of the 3D templating were comparable with those of other primary diagnosis, while intra-planner reliability of cup sizes was fair regardless of diagnosis.