Abstract
Introduction
It is thought that socioeconomic status and cultural upbringing influence the patient based outcomes of total joint arthroplasty. Previous studies have shown that patients in a lower socioeconomic class had surgery at an earlier age, increased comorbidities, increased severity of symptoms at presentation, and less satisfaction with the outcome. The purpose of this study was to compare the 1) reasons for undergoing total joint replacement and 2) satisfaction with the outcome among patients in different cultures and socioeconomic categories. We hypothesized that the overall reasons for undergoing surgery would be similar among all groups.
Method
Patients undergoing total hip or knee arthroplasty were divided into groups based on their country of residence and socioeconomic status. The patients were asked to rank their reasons for undergoing surgery preoperatively from 1 to 4 according to importance. They were also asked to state how much relief of pain or improvement in function they expected to obtain. They were then asked to complete a questionnaire assessing their satisfaction with surgery 6 months post-operatively. These results were then compared across the three groups.
Results
Thirty Nepalese patients and 10 American patients who received total hip or knee arthroplasty as part of a charitable outreach program were compared with 20 age and sex matched American patients who electively underwent total hip or knee arthroplasty. In both the Nepalese and outreach American patients, pain relief followed by improvement in performing everyday actions were listed as the most important reasons for undergoing surgery. The control group of American patients who sought surgery electively listed pain relief followed by improvement in performing individual activities as the main reasons for undergoing surgery. As compared to the other groups, the elective patients ranked athletic improvement higher as a reason for undergoing surgery. A review of the post-operative questionnaires completed by the Nepalese and American outreach patients showed that all were satisfied with the outcome of surgery and reported improvement in pain and the ability to perform individual as well as everyday activities. The postoperative questionnaires completed by the elective American patients showed satisfaction with the surgery, however, they reported less improvement in all functional categories.
Conclusion
We found that, despite socioeconomic status, the reasons for undergoing total joint arthroplasty were similar among all groups. Pain relief was the most important reason for having surgery. There was a tendency for elective patients to rank participation in athletic activities higher than those in the lower socioeconomic groups. All patients were satisfied with their outcomes. However, the degree of subjective improvement among elective patients was less than that in lower socioeconomic groups. This may be due to the fact that, due to their lack of access to care, patients in lower socioeconomic groups had more severe disease prior to surgery.
