Abstract
Introduction
The crescent sign is thought to be an early indicator of collapse in osteonecrosis of the femoral head. However, the formation mechanism of the crescent sign is still not quite clear. The purpose of this study was to utilize the two-dimensional finite element model analysis (FEA) technique to analyze mechanical function of different structures and intraosseous fluid in the femoral head under the stress of physiological loading. We wished to answer the following question: which structure or structures' failure are the main causes of collapse in osteonecrosis of the femoral head (ONFH)?
Methods
Based on two femoral head specimens obtained during THA (one with osteonecrosis of the femoral head with crescent sign formation and the other with most of the cancellous bone eroded by tumor cells without collapse), three groups of ten models were designed. Group A were standard femoral heads composed of subchondral plate, cancellous bone, intraosseous fluid, and cortical bone with 50 mm in diameter, Group B included ONFH, and Group C was based on a tumor-eroded femoral head. Previously reported mechanical property parameters were used in the FEA calculation. The strain and Von Mieses stress mechanics parameters of fifteen points (with the same coordinates) in the junction between subchondral plate and cancellous bone were harvested and compared.
Results
In the model, Group B3 (around the fissure region), had strains 12 times and Von Mieses' stresses 4.5 times higher than the values in same region of Group A1. Strain and Von Mieses stresses were concentrated in the fissure region and in the junction of the subchondral plate and the cancellous bone of the necrotic region.
Conclusion
All three; the subchondral plate, cancellous bone, and intraosseous fluid, together played an important role for the femoral head to bear physiological loads. It is the fissure in the subchondral plate caused by the resorption that; 1) provides a channel for the intraosseous fluid to outflow and makes the necrotic region in both the subchondral plate and the cancellous bone lose mechanical support from the intraosseous fluid, and 2) destroys the function of the subchondral plate as a thin shell structure, making the stress and strain concentrate in the junction of the subchondral plate and the cancellous bone of the necrotic region. Concentrated stress leads to fracture of the junction between the subchondral plate and the cancellous bone and the formation of a crescent sign.
