Abstract
Introduction
Scaphoid fracture is the most common undiagnosed fracture. Occult scaphoid fractures occur in 20-25 percent of cases where the initial X-rays are negative. Currently, there is no consensus as to the most appropriate investigation to diagnose these occult frctures. At our institution MRI has been used for this purpose for over 3 years. We report on our experience and discuss the results.
Materials and methods
All patients with occult scaphoid fractures who underwent MRI scans over a 3 year period were included in the study. There was a total of 619 patients. From the original cohort 611 (98.7%) agreed to have a scan, 6 (0.97%) were claustrophobic and did not undergo the investigation and 2 (0.34%) refused an examination. 86 percent of the cases were less than 30 years of age. Imaging was performed on a one Tiesla Siemen's scanner using a dedicated wrist coil. Coronal 3mm T1 and STIR images were obtained using a 12cm field of view as standard. Average scanning time was 7 minutes.
Results
The majority of the scans were performed within 2 weeks of the request. The breakdown of results is as follows: Normal 45%; Scaphoid bruise 10%; Scaphoid fracture 9%; Distal radius fracture 8%; Distal radius bruise 7%; TFCC tear 4%; Wrist ganglion 3%; Basal thumb arthritis 3%; Miscellaneous 12%. We did not have any missed scaphoid fractures during this period.
Conclusions
-
Patients with a clinically suspected scaphoid fracture could have a wide range of possible diagnoses.
-
Almost half the patients had a negative scan and therefore did not require further immobilisation/activity restriction.
-
It is possible to perform MRIs within a reasonable timeframe in a DGH setting.
-
Patient acceptance was very high (99%).
-
There were no missed diagnoses.
-
Scaphoid bruising could be picked up and consequently unnecessary immobilisation avoided.
-
In patients with other diagnoses a reliable prognosis could be given.
