Abstract
The aim of this study was to assess the risks and benefits of mini-incision TKR. The limited exposure afforded by the small skin incision in the new technique of mini-incision TKR has the potential for increasing the risk of mal-positioning of components. Minor mal-positioning of components has the potential to increase polyethylene wear and may lead to early loosening and poor functioning of the TKR. The literature supports the concept that alignment within +/- 3 degrees of neutral mechanical alignment in the coronal plane is associated with a better outcome. If the mechanical axis falls outside this range it may have up to a 30% failure rate at 10 years.
We report the results of 166 mini-incision TKR that have been undertaken in 154 patients (96F; 58M; mean age 72; mean BMI 29; 96% OA) since November 2003. The pre-operative mechanical axis ranged from 8 degrees valgus to 15 degrees varus. Surgery was undertaken with a precise skin incision and a midvastus split approach. Specialised cutting blocks were used to facilitate a smaller incision. The prosthesis inserted was a cemented Zimmer NexGen TKR of either posterior stabilised or cruciate retaining form.
Long leg weight bearing alignment radiographs were available in 52% of patients. The mechanical axis was measured in the coronal plane and found to lie within +/- 3 degrees of neutral in 86% of patients. This compares favourably with the current literature which reports the mechanical axis falling within this range in between 72% and 85% of cases.
We believe the mini-incision TKR is a safe, reliable and reproducible technique offering substantial savings to the patient and health service without compromising accuracy.