Abstract
Aim
Periprosthetic joint infections follow 1-3% of arthroplasty surgeries, with the biofilm nature of these infections presenting a significant treatment challenge1. Prevention strategies include antibiotic-loaded bone cement; however, increases in cementless procedures means there is an urgent need for alternative local antimicrobial delivery methods2. A novel, ultrathin, silica-based sol-gel technology is evaluated in this research as an anti-infective coating for orthopaedic prosthetic devices, providing local antibiotic release following surgery.
Method
Reduction in clinically relevant microbial activity and biofilm reduction by antimicrobial sol-gel coatings, containing a selection of antibiotics, were assessed via disc diffusion and microdilution culture assays using the Calgary biofilm device3. Proliferation, morphology, collagen, and calcium production by primary bovine osteoblasts cultured upon antibiotic sol-gel surfaces were examined, and cytotoxicity evaluated using Alamar blue staining and lactate dehydrogenase assays. Concentrations of silica, calcium and phosphorus compounds within the cell layer cultured on sol-gel coatings and concentrations eluted into media, were quantified using ICP-OES. Furthermore, cellular phenotype was assessed using alkaline phosphatase activity with time in culture.
Results
Low antibiotic concentrations within sol-gel had an inhibitory effect on clinically relevant biofilm growth, for example 0.8 mg ml-1 tobramycin inhibited clinically isolated S. aureus (MRSA) growth with an 8-log reduction in viable colony forming units. There was no significant difference in metabolic activity between untreated and sol-gel exposed primary bovine osteoblasts in elution-based assays. Reduction (2-fold) in metabolic activity in direct contact assays after 48 hours exposure was likely to be due to increased osteoinduction, whereas no impact upon cell proliferation were observed (p=0.92 at 14 days culture). The morphology of primary osteoblasts was unaffected by culture on sol-gel coatings and collagen production was maintained. Calcium containing nodule production within bovine osteoblastic cells was increased 16-fold after 14 days culture upon sol-gel.
Conclusions
The ultrathin sol-gel coating showed low cytotoxicity, strong biofilm reducing activity and antimicrobial activity, which was comparable to antibiotics alone, demonstrating that sol-gel delivery of antibiotics could provide local antimicrobial effects to inhibit PJI growth without the need for bone cement. Future work will develop and evaluate sol-gel performance in an ex vivo explant bone infection model which will reduce the need for animal experimentation.
