Abstract
Aim
Hand-disinfection (HD) is the most effective infection-prevention-measure. HD-performance of health care professionals (HCP) is usually evaluated by compliance observations (CO). The Hawthorne effect (HE) (HCP behave differently under observation) is considered to systematically increase HD-compliance-rates during CO. However, little is known about the specifications of the HE in health care settings. We hypothesized that, due to hand-hygiene`s known impact on patient safety and infection-prevention, the HE does not affect HD performance during direct patient care in patient-rooms.
Method
We conducted a prospective observational trial on an 18-bed surgical intensive care unit (ICU), a 12-bed surgical intermediate care unit (IMC) and a 36-bed surgical normal ward (NW) in a university hospital in Germany. Dispensers of hand sanitizers were equipped with an electronic monitoring system (EMS) (GWA Hygiene, Germany), which recorded the number of HDs per patient hour (HD/PH) and time and location of hand-disinfections. Locations were categorized as follows: 1. Patient rooms (PR); 2. Utility- and waste-disposal-rooms (UWR) and 3. Other rooms (hallways, kitchen, toilets etc.) (OR). Additionally trained infection-control-staff performed hand-hygiene CO according to WHO's Five Moments. The HD/PH during CO was compared to the HD/PH during the same time-periods without CO. Additionally the ratio between HD/PD-change during CO and mean-HD/PD of each ward during the study-period was determined in percentages. Descriptive and analytical statistics were calculated using R. P-values ≤ 0.05 were regarded as significant.
Results
587.128 HD were electronically recorded during the study-period (February 2022 to May 2023) and CO took place on 72 days. We recorded a significant increase of HD/PH during CO on all three wards in PRs (ICU: 21%, p<0.001; IMC: 11%, p=0.029; NW: 49%, p=0.047). Furthermore we detected a significant increase of HD/PH during CO on ICU (10%, p<0.001) and IMC (11%, p=0.033) in ORs. CO did not significantly affect HD/PH in ORs on NW and in UWR on all three wards.
Conclusions
In our setting, the number of hand-disinfections per patient-hour was significantly increased during compliance-observations especially in patient-rooms, where hand-hygiene is most crucial for infection-prevention. This indicates a lower everyday compliance to WHO`s hand-hygiene indications during patient care than determined by compliance-observations.
Acknowledgments
Paul-Hartmann AG financially supported this study.
