Abstract
Introduction
We assessed the role of four different High Tibial osteotomies (HTOs) for medial compartment osteoarthritis of knee (MCOA): Medial Opening Wedge High Tibial Osteotomy (MOWHTO), Focal Dome Osteotomy with Ilizarov Fixator (FDO-I), intra-articular, Tibial Condylar Valgus Osteotomy with plating (TCVO-P) and intra-articular plus extra-articular osteotomy with Ilizarov(TCVO-I); in correcting three deformity categories: primary coronal plane varus measured by Mechanical Axis deviation (MAD), secondary intra-articular deformities measured by Condylar Plateau Angle (CPA) and Joint Line Convergence Angle (JLCA), and tertiary sagittal, rotational and axial plane deformities in choosing them.
Materials and Methods
We retrospectively studied HTOs in 141 knees (126 patients). There were 58, 40, 26, and 17 knees respectively in MOWHTO, FDO-I, TCVO-P and TCVO-I. We measured preoperative (bo) And postoperative (po) deformity parameters.
Results
Average age was 56.1, average follow-up was 44.6 months. Mean bo-MAD in MOWHTO, FDO-I, TCVO-P, and TCVO-I were 8.8, −14.7, −11.5, −30.8% respectively. po-MAD was close to Fujisawa point in all except TCVO-P (45.2%). CPA corrected from −4.9° to −1.4° (p=0.02)and JLCA from 5.6° to 3.2° (p=0.001); CPA was better corrected by Intra-articular osteotomies (p=0.01).
Conclusions
MOWHTO corrects isolated mild primary varus deformities (bo-MAD≥ 0%). Primary varus (bo-MAD= −25% −0%) with associated tertiary sagittal, rotational, or axial deformities, without secondary intra-articular deformities needed FDO-I. Primary varus (bo-MAD= −25% −0%) with secondary intra-articular deformities, without tertiary deformities, corrected well with TCVO-P. TCVO-I corrects severe primary varus (bo-MAD< −25%) with large deformities in secondary and tertiary categories.
