Abstract
Introduction
Corrosion at modular junctions of total hip replacements has been identified as a potential threat to implant longevity, resulting in efforts to determine appropriate countermeasures. Visual scoring and volumetric material loss measurements have been useful tools to elucidate various clinical and design factors associated with corrosion damage. However, corrosion involves electron exchange that results in chemical changes to biomedical alloys, and electrochemical assessment may therefore be a more appropriate approach to understand the phenomenon. The purpose of this pilot study was to electrochemically distinguish the severity of corrosion in retrieved femoral heads. A secondary goal was to identify the potential of electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) as a method to identify different forms of corrosion damage.
Methods
Twenty femoral heads were identified from a larger study of total hip replacements, obtained as part of an ongoing multi- center IRB-approved retrieval program. Using a previously established 4-point scoring method, components were binned by taper damage: 10 components were identified as having severe damage, 7 with moderate damage and 2 with mild damage. One (1) unimplanted control was included to represent minimal corrosion damage. All components were then characterized using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy under the frequency domain: a 10 mV sinusoidal voltage, ranging from 20 kHz to 2 mHz, was applied to the taper of a femoral head (working electrode) filled with a 1M solution of PBS, a platinum counter electrode and a chlorided silver reference electrode. Absolute impedance at 2 mHz (|Z0.002|), and max phase angle (θ) were assessed relative to taper damage severity. After least-squares fitting of the EIS data to a Randles circuit with a constant phase element, circuit elements: polarization resistance (Rp), CPE-capacitance, and CPE-exponent were also evaluated. The seven (7) most severely corroded components were further examined with scanning electron microscopy to identify corrosion modes. For all statistical analyses, significance was determined at alpha=0.05.
Results
Taper damage was strongly correlated with both |Z0.002| (ρ = −0.857, p<0.001) and CPE-capacitance (ρ=0.913, p<0.001). Taper damage was moderately associated with max phase angle (ρ= −0.483, p=0.031), CPE-exponent (ρ= −0.653, p=0.002) and Rp (ρ=0.556, p=0.011). Log-log plots of the strongest predictors of taper damage (|Z0.002| and CPE- capacitance) identified some clustering among severely corroded components. SEM analysis identified evidence of grain/phase boundary corrosion on four components, all with log CPE-capacitance ≥ −4.4.
Discussion
The results of this pilot study highlight that electrochemical impedance spectroscopy is useful in determining corrosion severity in retrieved femoral heads, and may also identify intergranular corrosion attack. For an undamaged taper, the self- passivating behavior of CoCrMo creates a surface that opposes charge transfer, but greater corrosion appears to compromise this barrier. The observed trend of low impedance but high capacitance for severely corroded components with intergranular corrosion may signal charge storage at the boundaries of individual grains. Additional work is underway to characterize this behavior.