285. LONG-TERM OUTCOME OF DUQUENNOY LATERAL LIGAMENT REPAIR FOR CHRONIC ANKLE INSTABILITY: REPEATED EVALUATED IN THE SAME SERIES AT 3 AND 25 YEARS FOLLOW-UP

Abstract

Purpose of the study: The objectives of this work were to assess the stability of outcome achieved after Duquennoy procedure to tighten the lateral capsule-ligament structures of the ankle joint. To do this, we reviewed the same series of patients at 3 and 25 years follow-up to analyse the very long-term stability, laxity, and stiffness of the ankle joint and any osteoarthritic degradation.

Material and methods: From 1975 to 1986, we performed 75 Duquennoy procedures on the lateral capsule and ligament structures of the ankle joint. At mean 25 years follow-up (2007) we were able to review 28 ankles (27 patients) with the same method as applied in 1980 (3 years follow-up). The function outcome was assessed with the Good, Karlsson, Duquennoy and Tegner scores. Clinically, other than joint range of motion, were noted varus laxity or anterior drawer. Static x-rays were obtained to search for signs of osteoarthritis and stress images to measure talocrural laxity, in comparison with the preoperative figures and the 1980 data.

Results: There were two early technique failures (one persistent talocrural instability, one subtalar instability). Good and Karlsson scores were good or excellent in 92% of cases. Patients were very satisfied with the operation and the VAS was 8.9/10. Pain and occasional instability were reported by 27% of patients. There was no talocrural no subtalar stiffness at last follow-up. Radiographic laxity declined significantly between the preoperative value and the last review. Only one patient presented a narrow talocrural space (less than 50% narrowing). Eight patients had osteophytes whose presence was not correlated with poor functional outcome. These osteophytes were also present on the controlateral side. Importantly, there was no significant difference in the mean function scores between 3 and 25 years follow-up (Duquennoy score). Similarly joint range of motion and radiographic laxity remained stable over time.

Discussion: The Duquennoy procedure to tighten the lateral capsule and ligament structures is a simple technique with rare complications which provides excellent results both in terms of ligament stability and in terms of preservation from degenerative osteoarthritis. These results remain stable over time. Conversely, the technique has no action on the subtalar joint and should not be proposed as treatment for associated subtalar laxity, if diagnosed.