Abstract
Purpose of the study: High-energy varus or valgus ankle trauma causes severe injury to the capsule and ligaments. We describe a presentation associating massive tears of the lateral/medial collateral ligaments with a transversal wound of the corresponding malleolus. This wound results from excessive tension on the skin cause by the major varus/valgus. We have defined this injury as an open and severe ankle sprain (OSAS).
Material and method: This was a retrospective analysis. We search the databases of three participating centres using the corresponding diagnostic and therapeutic codes from January 2005 to January 2009. The identified files were screened to select patients with OSAS.
Results: There were 11 cases of OSAS. Eight involved the lateral side of the ankle and three the medial side. Mean age was 41 years (range 21–45). All patients were victims of a high-energy trauma (five motorcycle accidents) and four patients had fallen from a high point. Associated injuries were tendon section (n=3), section of the deep fibular nerve (n=2), and section of the anterior tibial artery (n=1). Pneumarthrosis was the only visible anomaly on the plain x-rays of seven ankles. Diagnosis was confirmed preoperatively in all cases clinically with varus-valgus stress manoeuvres.
Conclusion: OSAS is a rare misleading injury. Confusion with a common wound is possible. The risk is to miss acute instability and thus its treatment. The diagnosis should be proposed for all transversal wounds without contusion over the malleolus with normal x-rays.
Correspondence should be addressed to Ghislaine Patte at sofcot@sofcot.fr