Abstract
A consensus on total hip arthroplasty (THA) concluded that the major remaining issues of concern included the long-term fixation of the joint replacement, osteolysis due to poluethylene (PE) wear debris which often leads to aseptic loosening. Alumina ceramics had been extensively used in medicine, and we started using the alumina ceramic for THA bearing surface in hopes to reduce the PE debris. It was because alumina ceramics is advantageous for precision machining compared with metal materials, and its hardness is higher than that of metal materials. Also, to augment cement–bone bonding, we interposed hydroxyl apatite (HA) granules at the cement–bone interface, so called “Interface Bioactive Bone Cement (IBBC) technique”. HA granules (2–3 g) were smeared on the bone surface of the acetabulum and femur just before cementing. In this study, we evaluated 19–22 years clinical results of THA with alumina ceramic head combined with PE cup fixated IBBC technique.
Total 285 joints (212 patients) were implanted by one senior surgeon from January 1986 to December 1988, and 265 joints (192 patients) were traceable. Alumina ceramic femoral head of 28 mm in diameter and acetabular cup of the conventional PE sterilized with ethylene oxide gas were used in all patients. The PE cup and stem were fixed with IBBC technique in all cases. The presence of radiolucent line, loosening and osteolysis were observed using radiograph of the traceable cases. The locations of radiolucent lines were identified according to the zones described by DeLee and Charnley for acetabular cups and the zones described by Gruen et al. for femoral stems. The in vivo wear of 21 PE acetabular cups for 19.0–21.9 years (mean 20.3 years) was measured from the latest radiographs using computer assistant technique with Vector Works 10.5 software.
Features of the clinical radiograph images of the IBBC case were classified as follows: the radiolucent line represented “gap” between the HA layer and the cement; the loosening represented “opening” between the HA layer and the cement. For the quantitative analysis, we divided the surrounding bones of the THA into several zones as done in the previous studies. The “gap” appeared in zone 4 in three joints (1.4 %), in zone 3 in two joints (0.9 %) of acetabular cup. In femoral side, in zone 1 in four joints (1.8 %) in zone 7 in one joint (0.4 %). The “opening” appeared in three acetabular cup (1.4 %). Since no opening was appeared in zone 3 or zone 4, however, no re-operation was needed. Images of osteolysis were seen one in zone 1 (0.5 %), and one in zone 2 (0.5 %) in acetabular side and two in zone 1 (0.9 %) of the femur. The mean linear wear rate of PE acetabular cups was 0.13 mm/year.
The fixation to the bone by the IBBC technique has been maintained for long term. We think that the result was brought by the biological integration between bone and HA granules. In conclusion, this study has shown satisfactory results of the cemented THA with ceramic head combined with PE cup for 19–22 years.
Correspondence should be addressed to Diane Przepiorski at ISTA, PO Box 6564, Auburn, CA 95604, USA. Phone: +1 916-454-9884; Fax: +1 916-454-9882; E-mail: ista@pacbell.net
