STUDYING ABERRANT GENE EXPRESSION IN OSTEOARTHRITIS: CAN CURRENT IN VITRO MODELS BE IMPROVED?

Abstract

Destruction of articular cartilage in osteoarthritis (OA) is mediated by proteases and cytokines, which are silenced by epigenetic mechanisms in normal chondrocytes, but aberrantly expressed in OA. This is associated with DNA de-methylation of specific CpGs in the promoter regions (Arthritis Rheum, 2005; 52:3110–24). A widely used in vitro model to study the transcriptional regulation in OA is treating monolayer cultures of normal articular chondrocytes with inflammatory cytokines (IL-1b, TNFa or oncostatin M (OSM)) and investigating gene expression after 8–24 hours. The cytokines up-regulate catabolic, but down-regulate chondrocytic genes. However, whether this up- or down regulation is maintained after cytokine withdrawal is rarely investigated. In OA, the expression of catabolic genes is maintained in absence of cytokines and is transmitted to daughter cells, suggesting that epigenetic changes have resulted in permanent up-regulation. We asked whether it is possible to reproduce the epigenetic changes in vitro. Hence we compared gene expression and DNA methylation status in short-term (24h) versus long-term (2–3 weeks) cultures and, in particular, investigated the effects of cytokine withdrawal on these parameters.

Healthy chondrocytes, harvested from human femoral heads after hemiarthroplasty, were cultured in monolayer and passaged once (P1). For short-term culture, the P1 chondrocytes were divided into control culture or cultures with one-shot of IL-1b/OSM, harvested after 24h and 72h. For long-term culture, the cells were cultured with or without IL-1b/OSM, the latter added twice a week. Half the cells were harvested at confluence (3 weeks) and the other halves were passaged again and cultured without cytokines until confluence (2–3 weeks). RNA and genomic DNA were extracted from the same sample. IL-1b, MMP-3, MMP-13 and COL2A1 expression was quantified by real-time PCR. The percentage of cells with DNA methylation at the CpG site at −299bp of IL-1b promoter (a key CpG site) was quantified by a method we reported previously (Epigenetics, 2007; 2: 86–95).

As expected, expression of IL-1b MMP-3, MMP-13 had increased 100–4500-fold 24h after IL-1b/OSM treatment, but decreased considerably after cytokine withdrawal. COL2A1 expression was virtually abolished by IL-1b/OSM and not regained after 72h. The % DNA methylation did not change during the 72h. Repeated treatment with IL-1b/OSM in long-term culture also increased expression of IL-1b and the MMPs. However, this time expression was maintained or even increased after cytokine withdrawal and passaging. Expression inversely correlated with DNA methylation, which dropped from 59% to 35%. This de-methylation was preserved after passaging and cytokine withdrawal.

Conclusion: The widely used short-term cytokine-treated monolayer cultures of articular chondrocytes do not approximate the in vivo situation, where long-term aberrant expression correlates with DNA de-methylation. However, long-term treatment can mimic the loss of DNA methylation, which results in increased gene expression that is maintained after cytokine withdrawal. This model will facilitate studies on the mechanisms of DNA de-methylation, which might ultimately lead to novel therapeutic approaches for the treatment of OA