A REVIEW OF 40 CASES OF TUMORS OF THE CALCENUM: SCOTISH BONE TUMOR REGISTRY

Abstract

Introduction: Authors aim to present an interesting series of calcaneal tumors accrued from Scottish Bone Tumor Registry. The available literature is largely limited to the case reports. Bony tumors of the foot account for approximately 3% of all osseous tumors (1), of which Calcaneal location is the second most common site after the metatarsals in the foot. This study describes tumors of varying aetiology with regard to epidemiology, clinical features, diagnostic findings, treatment modalities and outcome.

Material and Methods: This study is a retrospective review of the medical records and imaging modalities of forty patients with calcaneal tumors which were accrued from Scottish Bone Tumor Registry between January 1954 and December 2006. Patient demographics including presentation characteristics, and delay in the presentation from the onset of symptoms were noted. Plain radiographs followed by further imaging with CT, MR and Bone scanning were reviewed. Size, location and spread of the tumors were noted based on imaging modalities. The type of biopsy, histological diagnosis, type of resection and adjuvant therapy was noted. All patients were followed-up clinically and radiologically for a minimum of 2 yrs or until death

Results: There were 28 primary benign, 11 primary malignant and 1 secondary malignant tumors. In the cohot of 40 patients 26 were male and 14 females with mean age of 27 years. Pain (37/40), swelling (27/40) and restriction of movements (25/40) were the main presenting features. Pathological fractures were found in 4 patients. Mean duration of symptoms was 12 months. Histological diagnoses included Osteoid Osteoma (4/40), PVNS (4/40), Chondroblastoma (3/40), Simple bone cyst (3/40), ABC (3/40), GCT (3/40), Osteochondroma (2/40), Chondroblastoma, Enchondroma, Fibrous Histiocytoma and Glomus tumour (1 case each). Chondrosarcoma, Ewing’s and Paget’s sarcoma (2 cases each), Osteosarcoma, Spindle cell and Pleomorphic Sarcoma (1 case each). Thirty eight patients underwent operative management.

Summary: Current study is one of the largest reported series of calcaneal tumors. A wide variety of lesions seem to involve patients from different age groups and either sex. Presentation features include mainly pain and swelling aggravated by walking. Radiological features may differ than those reported for common locations for the given tumor type. The recurrence rate for benign bone forming as well as cartilage tumors seem to be low provided adequate curettage or excision has been carried out. Whereas most benign lesions can be managed with limb salvage, below knee amputation sees to be a standard operation for primary malignant tumors. Metastatic lesions have poor survival prognosis.