HAMSTRING SHIFT TEST: IS IT A MEASURE OF CONTRIBUTORY KNEE FLEXION DEFORMITY?

Abstract

Purpose: The aim of this study was to see if there is any relationship between a positive hamstring shift test, which is a measure of knee flexion deformity after eliminating pelvic tilt with anterior pelvic tilt during the gait cycle.

Methods: We included all patients with cerebral palsy who had a gait analysis and a full physical assessment including measurement of the popliteal angle and hamstring shift test between August and December 05. The difference in measurement of knee flexion between the popliteal angle at 90 degrees and the hamstring shift test was termed hamstring length (HL). There were 33 patients of which 9 [18 limbs] were selected who fulfilled the criteria of a significant positive hamstring shift [> 10 degrees difference]. Maximum dynamic hip extension and average pelvic tilt were estimated from the gait analysis graph. SPSS13.0 was used to analyse the data.

Results: Mean HL was found to be 15.28 degrees. 6 (33.3%) patients had average pelvic tilt < 5 degrees, 8 (44.4%) was between 5–10 degrees and 4 (22.2%) patients had pelvic tilt of more than 10 degrees. The data had a normal distribution. There was no co relation between HL and pelvis tilt [p value:0.363 and r= −0.228.] or between average anterior pelvic tilt and the hip fixed flexion deformity. (p=0.361). However, it was found that maximum dynamic hip extension had strong negative association with average pelvic tilt (p=0.05, r = −0.455).

Conclusion: This study suggests that hamstring shift test does not have any correlation with pelvic tilt. In patients with a positive hamstring shift test, correcting the pelvic tilt will not correct the flexion deformities of the knee.