THE EFFECT OF IMPLEMENTATION OF EUROPEAN WORKING TIME DIRECTIVE ON THE CURRENT ORTHOPAEDIC TRAINING BY MULTICENTRIC HIP FRACTURE REAUDIT IN ENGLAND

Abstract

Aim: Our aim was to find the effect of implementation of European working time directive on current Orthopaedic training in England. Hip fracture surgery is one of the most frequently performed operation on the trauma lists and hence it is considered mandatory to independently able to perform hip fracture surgery in the registrar training curriculum.

Methods: The audit was performed over four month period in 2007 (1st April to 31st July) collating information on 1010 hip fracture patients undergoing surgery in 14 NHS hospitals in the North Western deanery of England. We have analysed the results of the this and have identified a potential area of concern.

Results: An orthopaedic trainee of registrar level(Speciality trainee year 3–6) was the lead surgeon in 37% of cases while only 4% of operations were performed by a Speciality trainee year 1–2 or Foundation year 2 (senior house officer grade) in 2007. These findings varied amongst the audited hospitals but in one hospital, trainees operated on only 12% of hip fractures. Overall, a trust grade surgeon (non-training grade) was the lead surgeon in 24% of cases. Comparing with the previous audits performed in the same hospitals, the number of hip fracture operations performed by trainees have reduced drastically. In 2003 and 2005 audits, Orthopaedic registrar’s operated on 52 % and 50% of hip fractures respectively. Similarily senior house officers had hands on experience on 11% and 9% of hip fractures in 2003 and 2005 respectively. There is a definite trend suggesting decrease in number of operations by trainees since the implementation of European working time directive as it has been introduced in a phased manner since 2004. In NHS, Current target is to achieve it fully by next year which may make the situation even worse from training point of view.

Discussion: European working time directive has reduced the working hours, leading to decreased hours of surgical training. On the other hand, the modernising medical curriculum (MMC) emphasises demonstration and record keeping of core competencies of surgical skills. The Orthopaedic Competence Assessment Project (OCAP) and the Intercollegiate Surgical Curriculum Project (ISCP) expects trainees to achieve core competencies in key procedures such as hip fracture surgery. In the context of shorter training and reduced working hours, to achieve these core competencies it is imperative to maximise operative exposure and experience for trainees. If the findings of this reaudit in England are mirrored elsewhere in Europe, the implications for orthopaedic training are significant. We are setting very high standards for training on one side but on practical grounds, not able to achieve the requirements set by educational bodies like OCAP and ISCP.