LYMPHOCYTE ACTIVATION AND CYTOKINE RELEASE IN LOW-CARBIDE METAL-ON-METAL TOTAL HIP ARTHROPLASTY

Abstract

Introduction: Metal-on-metal (MoM) articulations for THA are used successfully from CoCr-alloys. Low or high carbon hydride metals contain less or more than 0.2% carbon in the alloy. The systems show encouraging clinical results and lower rates of aseptic loosening in midterm results. Hypersensitivity reactions to high carbide MoM articulations were reported. The immune response is characterized by a perivascular T-/B-lymphocyte infiltration of the capsular tissue around the hip replacement. The present study examines if lymphocytic reactions are present in low carbide MoM THA and if distinct cytokines are released to joint fluids. Retrieval tissues from 28 patients were used. Joint fluids were aspirated at the time of surgery.

Materials and Methods: Tissues were collected from 25 patients undergoing 26 aseptic revisions of MoM THA (CoCrMo, Sikomet^®, Plus Orthopaedics). The patients had following symptoms: Hip and femoral pain; recurrent dislocation and clicking noises. 8 patients had osteolysis, 12 patients showed a metallosis. The peripros-thetic tissues were examined by standard histology and immunohistochemistry. Joint fluids were frozen at the time of surgery. The control groups were patients with osteoarthritis of the hip (n=10), revisions from Al2O3-UHMWPE articulations (n=6), revisions of MoM with hypersensitivity reaction (n=18), and MoM without hypersensitivity reactions (n=8). The fluids were analyzed for various Interleukins, Il-1 receptor antagonist, G-CSF, GM-CSF, IFN gamma, MIP-1ß, and TNF-α.

Results: 18 out of 26 cases showed diffuse and follicular lymphocyte infiltrations in the revision tissues. Perivas-cular T- and B-lymphocytes and few macrophages were also seen. In low and excessive metallosis no lymphocytes were observed. The tissue response in low carbide MoM is similar to high carbide MoM. Analysis of the cytokine profile in the joint fluids showed markers of osteoclast activation (Il-6 and −10) in all MoM articulations. TNF-α increase was increased in all loosening groups but was further increased in MoM. Il-5, IFN gamma, MIP-1ß, and GM-CSF were increased in all fluids from loosening cases but were further increased in MoM with lymphocyte activation.

Discussion: Activation of lymphocytes in failed MoM THA’s is not necessarily related to high carbide MoM. Hypersensitivity also occurred in low carbide MoM THA. The cytokine profiles in the joint fluids showed distinct characteristics. Il-6 and Il-10, markers of osteo-clast activation, were elevated in all cases of bone loss and osteolysis. The increase in TNF-α may account for a regulation of the OPG/RANKL system TNF-a which can induce osteolysis. The elevated levels of Il-5, IFN gamma, MIP-1ß, and GM-CSF in MoM failures with hypersensitivity represent markers of chemotaxis and lymphocyte activation may account for index markers of hypersensitivity reaction.