EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATIONS OF THE PRIMARY STABILITY OF PRESS-FIT CUPS IN THA IN DEPENDENCE OF INSERTION FORCE AND BONE QUALITY

Abstract

Introduction: To obtain secondary implant stability of acetabular press-fit cups, sufficient primary stability is essential. The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of cup insertion force and bone quality on the primary implant stability.

Materials and Methods: The experiments were carried out using two commercially available press-fit acetabular cups (Trident PSL, Stryker und EP-FIT PLUS, PLUS Ortho-peadics), comparable in design and with identical diameters, which were inserted axially into artificial bone by a female and a male surgeon. Two bone substitute material models were used. To imitate osteoporotic bone, a PMI-model (ROHACELL 110 IG, Gaugler & Lutz oHG) was employed. To simulate sclerotic bone, a composite-model made of a PMI-bloc with a 4 mm thick PVC-layer (AIREX C70.200, Gaugler & Lutz oHG) was used. The cups were inserted using an insertion device, equipped with a force sensor, and an 1100 g surgical hammer. Additionally, all experiments were carried out using a dynamic testing machine (25 kN, Instron) utilising insertion forces of 4.0 kN and 8.0 kN respectively. Primary implant stability was determined via lever-out tests using a static universal testing machine (Z050, Zwick/Roell).

Results: On average an insertion force of 4.8 kN (female) and 7.0 kN (male) using the PMI-model and 6.2 kN (female) and 7.5 kN (male) for the composite-model was assessed for the two different surgeons. The machined forces averaged 3.8 kN and 7.9 kN.

Lever-out-moments of 17 Nm were determined for both the PMI- and composite-model for the female surgeon using the PSL cup, whereas 27 Nm and 70 Nm, respectively, were reached for the EP-FIT shell.

For the male surgeon using the PSL cup, lever-out moments of 15 Nm and 30 Nm for the PMI- and composite-model respectively were determined. Insertion of the EP-FIT cup resulted in lever-out moments of 10 Nm using the PMI-model and 82 Nm using the composite-model.

The low machined insertion force led to average lever-out moments of 34 Nm for the PSL and 71 Nm for the EP-FIT cups using the composite-model. For the high machined force, the highest lever-out moments of 44 Nm and 99 Nm for the PSL and EP-FIT shells respectively were determined.

Conclusion: Using the composite-model (sclerotic bone), higher insertion forces lead to higher lever-out moments and hence higher primary implant stability for both tested cups. However, a high, non axial applied force can result in loss of stability using the PMI-model (osteoprotic bone). Compared to the manually inserted acetabular cups, the machined insertion resulted in higher primary stability for both implants and artificial bone types.