DOES PRE-OP KNEE CHONDRAL DAMAGE PREDISPOSE TO SUBSEQUENT PATELLA-FEMORAL OSTEOARTHRITIS? 10–15 YEAR FOLLOW-UP OF ELMSLIE-TRILLAT TIBIAL TUBERCLE TRANSFER OSTEOTOMIES FOR PATELLAR INSTABILITY

Abstract

We present 10–15 year follow-up of 33 patients who underwent Elmslie-Trillat osteotomy for severe patellar subluxation or dislocation. In the literature it has been reported that tibial tubercle osteotomy predisposes to subsequent patella-femoral arthritis, however it has never been documented if pre existent knee chondral damage has any role in this development. In our group all patients had pre-op knee arthroscopy performed and extant of chondral damage was documented. We pre-formed an evaluation by long-term follow-up to determined weather pre-op chondral damage was the cause of subsequent osteoarthritis of patella-femoral joint.

All patients were invited to attend outpatient clinic for clinical examination and knee radiographs and assessed by an independent research surgeon. Mean age at follow-up was 43 years and average follow-up was 10.5 years (range 10–15 years). 90% follow-up was achieved. Knee function was assessed by clinical scores (Lysholm knee score, American Knee Score, Oxford Knee score, Tegner and Insall knee scores) and three radiographs (AP, Lateral and Merchant views) were performed.

Four patients had developed significant arthritis and underwent joint arthroplasty. Majority of patients reported good results with no further dislocation. However we noticed that extant of pre-op chondral damage was a significant factor in subsequent development of patella-femoral arthritis. We will present our data which is unique as no previous such long-term results have been reported for tibial tubercle transfers followed-up for more than 10 years and have pre-op arthroscopic documented chondral damage.