MENTAL DISTRESS AND FUNCTIONAL OUTCOME BEFORE AND AFTER PRIMARY HIP REPLACEMENT – A MULTI-CENTRE PROSPECTIVE COHORT ANALYSIS.

Abstract

Introduction: We investigated the relationship between psychological distress and outcome after total hip replacement (THR) in the Exeter Primary Outcome Study (EPOS).

Materials & Methods: Data were collected from a number of centres across England between January 1999 and January 2002 for patients undergoing primary hip replacement using the cemented Exeter femoral component (Stryker). We recorded the Oxford Hip Score (OHS) for physical function and SF36 questionnaire for both physical and mental domain assessment annually for five years. We dichotomised the patients into the mentally distressed (MHS < 50) and the not mentally distressed (MHS ≥ 50) groups based on their pre-operative Mental Health Score (MHS) from the SF36 score.

Results: Complete data were available for 455 (407 not distressed and 48 distressed) patients. Pre-operative OHS and SF-36 score was significantly worse in the distressed group (both p< 0.001). Mean OHS improved from 43 to 20 at 1 year after surgery and remained the same thereafter in the non distressed group. In the mentally distressed group pre-operative mean OHS of 48 improved to 22 at 1 year after surgery. Maximum improvement in OHS occurred in the 1st yr after surgery. Mean MHS improved from 76 to 81 at 1 year after surgery and remained the same thereafter in the non distressed group. Mean MHS improved from 35 to 62 at 1 year after surgery, reaching 65 at 5 years after surgery in the mentally distressed group. The maximum improvement in MHS occurred in the 1st yr after surgery.

Conclusion: Pre-operative psychological distress did not compromise functional outcome after hip arthroplasty. There was a substantial improvement in mental distress in patients with mental distress prior to surgery. Both groups of patients experienced improvement in Oxford Hip Score, which was maximal by 1 year after surgery and was maintained over the 5 year follow up.