Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Full Access

NON-OPERATIVE MANAGEMENT OF ATLANTO-AXIAL FRACTURES: MAINTAINING RIGID IMMOBILIZATION UNTIL CT SCANNING CONFIRMS FRACTURE UNION IMPROVES OUTCOMES AND REDUCES THE NEED FOR SUBSEQUENT SURGERY



Abstract

Introduction: The management atlanto-axial fractures, particularly those of the odontoid peg, remains controversial. We managed patients with C1/C2 fractures non-operatively in rigid immobilization until CT-scanning confirmed bony union, rather than for the standard 3-month period. We examined whether this improved outcomes and reduced the need for surgery.

Method: All patients admitted to our unit with atlanto-axial fractures between 2001–2007 were retrospectively analyzed. All fractures had the ‘intention-to-treat’ conservatively in either halothoracic vest (85%) or Aspen collar (15%). Rigid immobilization was maintained until CT-scanning demonstrated bony fusion. Functional stability was subsequently assessed with flexion-extension radiographs after removal of rigid immobilization.

Results: Twenty-seven patients were studied. Nineteen had odontoid peg fractures (10 type II; 9 type III). The remainder consisted of 3 Hangman’s, 3 lateral mass and 2 atlas ring fractures. 83% of patients progressed to union at an average of 13.2 weeks (range 5–22). Six complications related to halo immobilization were observed (three skull perforations/pin-site infections). All of these patients progressed to union non-operatively.

Failure of non-operative management was deemed as non-union or poor patient tolerance of halo, and occurred in 4 patients (17%). All four had type II odontoid peg fractures, and had transarticular screw fixation. One postoperative complication of screw fracture was recorded.

Conclusion: Non-union rates of conservatively managed atlanto-axial fractures with standard 3-month rigid immobilization have been reported as high as 35%. In our series, CT-imaging to confirm bony union prior to removal of the rigid immobilization (prolonging immobilization where necessary) significantly lowered the rate of non-union and therefore the need for subsequent surgery.

Ethics approval: None Audit

Interest Statement: None

Correspondence should be addressed to BASS/BCSS c/o BOA, at the Royal College of Surgeons, 35–43 Lincoln’s Inn Fields, London, WC2A 3PE, England.