FIVE YEAR FOLLOW UP OF NECK PAIN PATIENTS.

Abstract

Purpose: Neck disorders, including both neck pain and injuries, are significant and increasing problem worldwide. The purpose of this study was to assess progression and current condition of patients with neck pain five years after initial treatment in the Back Pain Screening Clinic.

Study design: This study was a randomised cohort Level I study. We randomly selected and reassessed one hundred patients with the neck pain who were treated conservatively out of the first one thousand of patients seen in our clinic five years ago. Outcome measures included SF36 (PCS and MCS), ODI, VAS, HA and DS scores.

Methods and results: One hundred randomly selected patients were interviewed and assessed for initial complaint, progression of symptoms, time out of work, litigation, other treatments and BPSC treatment satisfaction. BPSC treatment consisted of the patient assessment, advice, education, reassurance or course of physiotherapy. All of the patients were treated conservatively. 46 male and 54 female patients with mean male age 44.85 years (SD=14.43) and mean female age 48.56 (SD=15.39) were included in the study. In 72 patients pain started spontaneously. 15 patients had pain related to industrial injury/RTA. 6 patients were excluded from the study (4 with no data available, 1 child, 1 death). Mean time out of work for patients with spontaneous onset pain was 3 weeks (SD 1.12) and for patients with industrial injury/RTA 29.24 weeks (SD 20.92) (p=0.003). Analyzing outcome measures first vs 5y showed: SF36 PCS mean 30.04 vs 51.24 (SD 7.18 vs 6.38) (p< 0.001), MCS mean 30.63 vs 53.0 (SD 11 vs 6.10) (p< 0.001), ODI 41.72 vs 13.22 (SD 19.65 vs 8.41) (p< 0.001), HA mean 8.72 vs 2.37 (SD 4.54 vs 1.32) (p< 0.001), DS mean 6.71 vs 2.01 (SD 4.12 vs 1.20) (p< 0.001) and VAS mean 4.32 vs 0.84 (SD 2.18 vs 1.03) (p< 0.001). Using the patient satisfaction questionnaire, 93% of patients found BPSC treatment useful.

Conclusion: Significant symptomatic improvement is found in this cohort group of patients five years after initial treatment in BPSC. Time out of work is significantly increased in patients pursuing litigation compared with patients with spontaneous onset of neck pain (3/52 vs 29.24/52, p=0.003).