BILATERAL SIMULTANEOUS ANTERIOR CRUCIATE LIGAMENT RECONSTRUCTION: A SAFE OPTION

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to investigate the safety and outcome of bilateral simultaneous ACL reconstruction. In patients presenting with an ACL-deficient knee, 2 – 4% have bilateral ACL deficiency. A staged or simultaneous approach can be adopted when the patient requires reconstructive surgery for both knees. We report a case series of 8 patients (6 male, 2 female, average age 30.4 years) who underwent bilateral simultaneous ACL reconstruction.

Simultaneous or bilateral ACL reconstruction using ipsilateral patella tendon graft has been reported as a safe procedure with outcome and complication rate no different to unilateral procedures. Considerable cost savings of simultaneous over staged procedures have also been described. There are no case series in the published literature that describe the use of hamstring tendon autograft for bilateral simultaneous ACL reconstruction.

We used two camera stack systems and instrument sets to allow for simultaneous bilateral surgery by two surgical teams. Quadrupled hamstring tendon graft was used in 4 patients although in one patient patella tendon graft was used on the second side due to poor quality of hamstring tendons. Patella tendon graft was also used in a further 4 patients. At two weeks all patients were able to discard crutches and were independent in mobility. There was no difference in outcome at one year between those patients undergoing bilateral simultaneous ACL reconstruction in comparison to the outcomes of unilateral ACL reconstruction with respect to Lysholm, Tegner and IKDC scores. The mean follow up period was 2.3 years.

Our results demonstrate that bilateral simultaneous ACL reconstruction is safe and cost effective. A simultaneous approach also has the benefit of reducing the overall period of rehabilitation required by the patient. We report good short-term functional outcome but no long-term data is yet available.