PROGRESSION OF CARTILAGE DEGRADATION IN OSTEOARTHRITIS MAY INVOLVE AUTOCRINE INDUCTION OF IL-1BETA AND LOSS OF DNA METHYLATION

Abstract

Osteoarthritis (OA) is characterised by progressive erosion of articular cartilage, which, once started, cannot be halted. The breakdown of cartilage is mediated by proteases, including MMP-3 and -13. These may initially be derived from the synovium but are also produced by OA chondrocytes, particularly in later stages of the disease. In normal articular chondrocytes, the proteases are not expressed and it has previously been shown that this is due, in part, to silencing by epigenetic mechanisms, in particular DNA methylation at so-called CpG sites (Arthritis & Rheumatism 52:3110–24). In OA, chondrocytes increasingly produce the enzymes and stably transmit the abnormal gene expression to daughter cells. This aberrant expression has been shown to be associated with an epigenetic “un-silencing” via demethylation of specific CpG sites within the promoter regions. Why and how this demethylation takes place is not known.

The pro-inflammatory cytokine IL-1beta is of potential importance in OA, where temporary synovitis could provide the cytokine. Moreover, it is well established that IL-1beta upregulates MMPs in chondrocyte monolayer cultures. We investigated whether the IL-1 mediated induction of MMPs was associated with DNA demethylation. Control chondrocytes were isolated from non-OA articular cartilage, obtained with ethical permission from patients with a femoral neck fracture, and expanded in monolayer culture. The cells from each patient were divided into pre-culture control, no-treatment control culture and IL-1 treated culture. When confluent, simultaneous RNA and DNA extraction was carried out. mRNA expression was analysed by RT-PCR and the methylation status of specific CpG sites within the promoters of MMP-3, -13, and IL-1â was determined in the same samples, using methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes and PCR. The pre-culture controls expressed type II collagen and low levels of MMP-3, but not MMP-13 nor IL-1beta. All IL-1 treated samples expressed high levels of MMP-3, -13, and, surprisingly, IL-1beta itself. As predicted, the large increases in MMP-3 and IL-1beta were associated with some loss of methylation at specific CpG sites in the promoter of these mediators with the strongest correlation between IL-1beta expression and promoter demethylation. IL-1beta thus induced its own expression, which was associated with loss of DNA methylation at one specific CpG site in the IL-1 promoter. If these in vitro results have relevance for the in vivo situation, then these findings suggest the following mechanisms for OA progression: An initial inflammatory episode in the synovium could induce IL-1beta in surface chondrocytes. Since this induction is associated with loss of DNA methylation, IL-1beta is now part of the expression repertoire of these chondrocytes and this abnormal expression is stably transmitted to daughter cells. IL-1 then could diffuse deeper into the cartilage to induce its own expression in adjacent chondrocytes, thus providing a continuous supply of IL-1beta even after synovial inflammation had abated. This may explain the unremitting progression of OA.