DEGENERATIVE ARTHRITIS IN THE ELBOW IN YOUNG ADULTS-IS IT UNICOMPARTMENTAL?

Abstract

Goodfellow & Bullough (1968) first described the pattern of articular cartilage wear in the elbow. More recent post mortem studies have shown that advanced degenerative changes can develop in the radio-capitellar (lateral) compartment of elbow joints of elderly subjects in which the humero-ulnar (medial) compartment remains remarkably well preserved. The significance of this post-mortem findings,in an elderly population, with unknown elbow symptom logy, who died from diverse causes, is unknown. There has been no clinically based,in vivo,study of this subject. Our study would support these observations, but indicates that symptomatic degenerative change occurs at a much earlier age than had previously been thought.

We have reviewed the findings in a consecutive series of 117 elbow arthroscopies performed on patients with elbow pain resistant to conservative treatments (age range 21–80 years: mean age 51 years). We documented established degenerative changes involving articular cartilage in 68 patients (59%). In this group we found that in 60 patients (88%) the degenerative changes were confined to the lateral compartment and contrasted with normal appearances of the articular cartilage of the medial compartment.

The findings presented in this work are in full agreement with previous work on the articular wear and biomechanics of the elbow joint. Previous studies which have been on cadaveric specimens, with findings of uncertain symptomatic relevance. To our knowledge, this finding has not previously been demonstrated in a symptomatic, young population. Unicompartmental lateral degeneration of the elbow is therefore a real clinical entity rather than a interesting post mortem finding. As such, it demands consideration in terms of investigation, diagnosis and treatment. It is likely that in the past, many patients have been misdiagnosed as having chronic lateral epicondylitis.

We consider that lateral compartment degenerative change is a distinct clinical entity. It begins in relatively young patients in whom the x ray appearance may be normal or near normal and is often diagnosed as lateral epicondylitis. Our observations taken together with the reported post mortem studies indicate that primary osteoarthritis of the elbow begins in the lateral compartment of the joint and may remain confined to the lateral compartment throughout life. We believe that new treatment strategies need to be developed specifically for patients with primary osteoarthritis as opposed to degenerative joint disease due to other causes.