Abstract
Background: Several factors can alter a cements viscosity and hence it’s handling characteristics. An in vitro study was performed to ascertain whether anecdotal observations of differences in handling between batches of the same cement brand existed.
Methods: 3 batches of Simplex P Tobramycin (SPT), Refobacin Bone Cement (RBC), SmartSet GHV (SSG) and Palacos R+G (PRG) were tested. 6 replicates of each batch were vacuum mixed and their viscosity in relation to time was measured in laboratory conditions (50 ±5% humidity and 23 ±1°C) using a rheometer. 6 replicates of each batch had their handling characteristics examined after they were hand mixed in theatre conditions.
Results: Inter and intra-batch variability was seen in the viscosity of all brands of cements tested. Inter-batch calculations were influenced by high intra-batch viscosity variability. The viscosity of RBC cement was very similar to SSG, but significantly different to PRG (p = 0.01 at 5N and p = 0.009 at 40 N).
Interpretation: Our results suggest that in clinical practice extrinsic factors such as preparation conditions and methods probably play a more important role than the cements intrinsic variability. However, variability in handling and viscosity will exist in all brands of cement prepared in theatre conditions and the surgeon needs to be aware why they may act differently.
Correspondence should be addressed to Ms Larissa Welti, Scientific Secretary, EFORT Central Office, Technoparkstrasse 1, CH-8005 Zürich, Switzerland