UNILATERAL NON-JOINTED EXTERNAL FIXATORS AS A DEFINITE TREATMENT FOR TIBIAL SHAFT FRACTURES

Abstract

PURPOSE: There is an argument in the literature regarding the use of intramedullary nail or the external fixation followed by intramedullary nail in tibial fractures with severe damage of soft tissues, threatened compartment syndrome, open type IIIA fractures and in polytrauma patients. The purpose of this retrospective study was to evaluate the results of non-jointed external fixators as a definite treatment for these type of tibial shaft fractures.

MATERIAL AND METHOD: 86 patients (91 tibial shaft fractures) were treated at the authors’ institute with a non-jointed external fixator. The mean patient age was 35 years (range, 15–80). There were 70 male and 16 female patients. The average time of surgery from the accident was 10 hours. The indications for application an external fixator was: severe damage of the soft tissues in 11 fractures, an incipient compartment syndrome in 12 fractures, open type III Gustilo fractures in 57, and 11 tibia fractures in polytrauma patients. According to AO classification 46 fractures were type A, 32 type B and 13 type C.

RESULTS: The average follow up was 2.9 years (ranged, 1–5 years). The average operative time was 50 min. Complications included: 3 non-unions, 5 delayed unions, 1 malunions, 1 tibia shortening, 3 superficial infections of soft tissues in open fractures, 26 pin infections and 1 osteomyelitis in open fractures. In 2 patients fat embolism was diagnosed while pulmonary embolism was a complication in 2 patients. Deep venous thrombosis (DVT) developed in 5 patients. A re-operation was performed in 11 out of 91 fractures. Change of the method was necessary in 2 out of 91 fractures. The primary callus in 10 out of 91 fractures was due to the stiffness of the unilateral non-jointed external fixators and did not influence the final results. Mean time of fracture union for the open fractures that did not require change of the method nor bone graft was 25 weeks, while for the closed fractures was 18 weeks. The dynamization of the system and partial weight bearing was started at 6 weeks and all the patients had full weight bearing by the 12th week.

CONCLUSION: The unilateral external fixators were the definite treatment in 88 out of 91 fractures. The unilateral external fixators can be used as a definite treatment for tibial shaft fractures in the majority of the cases. Re-operation or change of the method is unusual and must be performed only when there is a delay in callus formation.