SURGERY VS RADIOTHERAPY IN EWING’S SARCOMA OF THE EXTREMITIES: EXPERIENCE OF A SINGLE INSTITUTION

Abstract

Introduction: The role of surgery for local control in the multimodal management of Ewing’s sarcoma has substantially increased during the past 20 years. However, selection bias due to location (extremities vs axial skeleton) and relatively non-homogeneous treatment received by patients in multi-institutional trials may limit objective evaluation and comparison of the relative role of surgery and radiation therapy in this setting. Purpose of this study was to review a large series of patients homogeneously treated at a single institution.

Methods: 268 patients with non-metastatic Ewing’s sarcoma of the extremities treated by contemporary multimodal management were reviewed. Chemotherapy was administered according to 4 sequential protocols of adjuvant (1) and neoadjuvant (3) treatment. Local control consisted of surgery in 136 patients, surgery and radiation therapy in 70 patients, and radiation therapy in 60 patients. Two patients underwent only chemotherapy.

Results: The 5-year event-free survival (EFS) and overall survival (OS) were 62 and 69 per cent respectively. The rates of 5-year EFS and local control were significantly lower in patients treated with radiation therapy compared to patients treated by surgery or surgery and radiation therapy (48 vs 66 per cent, p=0.002; 80 vs 94 per cent, p= 0,0001). In group 3 (Radiation Therapy only) there were also 6 secondary malignancies.

Conclusion: Surgery was associated with better survival and local control in this series. In our opinion, surgery should always be considered in the local treatment of Ewing’s sarcoma of the extremities. Postoperative Radiation Therapy must be added in cases of inadequate surgical margins.