INTERLOCKED NAILING OF THE FEMUR WITH THE BROOKER–WILLS NAIL: OUR EXPERIENCE

Abstract

Intramedullary Nailing is now accepted as the standard treatment for most femoral diaphyseal fractures. Most intramedullary nails are designed for proximal and distal locking with screws. We describe our experience with the Brooker Wills femoral nail. This nail is unique as distal fixation is achieved with as transverse fixator deployed through slots in the nail, a concept first enunciated by deCamargo in 1952. The fins of the fixator pierce the distal cortex when deployed thereby conferring rotational stability. The entire nail (including the proximal and distal fixation devices) can be inserted through a single proximal incision in the skin.

We treated 17 patients with femoral shaft fractures using this system. 93% of the patients were males. Motor vehicle accidents accounted for 80 % of the fractures. Most fractures involved the middle third of the femur (54%), followed by distal third (33%) and proximal third (13%). 67 % of the fractures showed Winquist and Hansen Grade 3 or 4 comminution.

All the nailings were performed in the supine position. Static locking was done in 16 cases. Post operative weight bearing was individualized with 86% of the patients bearing full weight before the end of 16 weeks. The average time to full weight bearing was 14 weeks.

The mean time to union was 17.1 weeks, with proximal, middle and distal third fractures showing average healing times of 19, 15.6 and 18.8 weeks respectively. All the fractures united. There was one case of delayed union. Intra-operative complications included–inability to deploy the distal fixator in one case and unwinding of the reamer in another case. There was one case of superficial infection where a patient developed a sinus over the metallic fin of the distal fixation device, which had penetrated the cortex. This healed after the distal fixation device was removed. There was one case of proximal nail migration, but the fracture went onto union with some limb shortening.

Results were evaluated using the scoring system devised by Sanders etal (1991). The functional criteria in their scoring system include- knee flexion, presence of pain, femur deformity, walking distance, stair climbing and pre injury functional status. We achieved excellent results in 53% of patients, good- 27%, fair–13 % and poor-7%.

We feel that the main advantage of the Brooker Wills Nail is the ease of distal locking. This saves time and also leads to lower level of radiation exposure, as the image intensifier is sparingly used for distal locking. In fact, this nail is an attractive option in centres which lack an image intensifier. We achieved good results with this nailing system and feel that it is an acceptable alternative to other nailing systems with conventional locking systems with screws.