Abstract
Purpose: Many surgeons are now performing hip arthroplasty using a minimally invasive technique with the aim of reducing muscle damage and improving rehabilitation. We compared the learning curve of two MIS THA approaches: the two-incision mini and a modified Watson-Jones (G3) approach.
Methods: A retrospective review of 47 consecutive patients who underwent a THA using an MIS approach was conducted. All patients received an uncemented acetabular cup (Trilogy–Zimmer) fixed with 1 or 2 screws, and an uncemented femoral stem (ML taper, fiber metal taper, fully porous coated–Zimmer). Note was made of BMI, surgical time, incision length, blood loss, component positioning, hospital stay and perioperative complications.
Results: Twenty-one patients received a G3 and 26 received a 2 incision mini approach. The average BMI was 29.7 and 26.1 respectively. Average acetabular inclination was 37 for the G3 and 42 for the 2-incision mini. On average, the femoral component was positioned in neutral in the coronal plane for both approaches. Average surgical time was 121minutes for the G3 and 166 minutes for the 2-incision which also includes fluoros-copy time. Hospital stay averaged 5.4 and 6.8 days respectively. The skin incision averaged 8.9 cm for G3 a total of 9.8cm for 2-incision. Perioperative complications for the G3 included 1 lateral femoral cutaneous nerve palsy, 1 DVT, 1 PE and 1undisplaced intraoperative acetabular fracture. Complications for the 2-incision mini included 5 intraoperative fractures, 7 nerve injuries, 1 wound infection, 1 infection requiring revision and 1 PE.
Conclusions: The G3 minimally invasive approach for THA has advantages over the 2-incision mini: shorter operative time, no need for fluoroscopy, fewer days in hospital, shorter total incision length and lower complication rate. The G3 approach also offers the opportunity to bail out to a traditional approach, by extending the incision, should this be necessary.
Correspondence should be addressed to Cynthia Vezina, Communications Manager, COA, 4150-360 Ste. Catherine St. West, Westmount, QC H3Z 2Y5, Canada
