Abstract
Introduction The unacceptably low fusion rate with stand-alone ALIF cages led to the practice of combining ALIF with posterior instrumentation. Recently ALIF combined with anterior lumbar plate fixation has been promoted to obviate the need for additional posterior surgery. The purpose of this study is to compare the multidirectional flexibility of ALIF combined with posterior instrumentation (either translaminar facet screws or pedicle screws) to that combined with anterior plate fixation.
Methods Ten human lumbar cadaveric motion segments were tested in the following sequence: (i) intact, (ii) stand alone ALIF cages, (iii) ALIF and anterior lumbar plate, (iv) ALIF with translaminar facet screws, (v) ALIF with pedicle screws. In each condition, the specimens were tested under bending moments of 0–8 Nm flexion, 0–6 Nm extension, 0–6 Nm lateral bending and 0–5 Nm axial rotation. 3D motions were measured using an optoelectronic motion monitoring system.
Results The ALIF cages decreased the ROM in the sagittal and frontal planes (p< 0.05). Their effectiveness improved in the sagittal plane with the combination of either anterior plate or posterior fixation (p< 0.05). There was no statistical difference between the ALIF/ Plate and translaminar screws or pedicle screws in flexion-extension and axial rotation ROM. There was a difference in the lateral bending ROM between the ALIF with anterior plate and ALIF with either translaminar facet screws or ALIF with pedicle screws (p< 0.05) favouring posterior fixation. However there was no statistical difference between the combined ROM for ALIF/Plate and translaminar screws or pedicle screws.
Discussion This study shows that the stability achieved with the combination of ALIF with an anterior plate is comparable to that achieved with posterior instrumentation with translaminar facet screws or pedicle screws. This suggests that sufficient segmental stability may be provided by anterior plating, obviating the need for a concomitant posterior approach.
The abstracts were prepared by Assoc Prof Bruce McPhee. Correspondence should be addressed to him at the Division of Orthopaedics, The University of Queensland, Clinical Sciences Building, Royal Brisbane Hospital, Herston, Brisbane, 4029, Australia.
