Abstract
Introduction: Aseptic loosening remains the commonest causes of failure of total hip arthroplasty. Cement mantle defects are associated with aseptic loosening. This study aimed to determine a correlation between surgical approach and cement mantle defects in the Stanmore Hip. The Stanmore total hip replacement was chosen because it has greater than an eighty-five percent survivorship over 25 years and unlike other prostheses with comparable results such as the Charnley total hip, it remains essentially unchanged to date.
Method: This was a retrospective review of all Stanmore hips. AP and lateral radiographs were available for 62 patients operated via the posterior approach and 100 patients operated via the anterolateral approach. The mean cement thickness in all fourteen Gruen zones was estimated for each patient. Gruen zones IV and XI, representing the stem tip, were removed from data relating to mantle thickness. Mantles were graded as less than 2mm, 2–5mm, 5–10mm and more than 10mm. Alignment was also measured.
Results: Fifty-nine percent (32/54) of cement mantle defects are seen in Gruen zones VIII to XIV. The mean cement mantle thickness in A-L approach was 3.11mm compared to 4.23mm with the posterior approach. This corresponds with the frequency of cement mantle defects occurrence. No cement defects were seen in Gruen zones IV or XI. Using the anterolateral approach, defects were observed in 49 out of 1200 zones (4.08%) and using the posterior approach in 6 out of 744 zones (0.81%). With the anterolateral approach, 19 out of 100 cement mantles (19%) had defects, compared to only 3 out of 62 (4.84%) with the posterior approach. Defects were most commonly seen in zones I, V, VIII and XII, which corresponds to valgus and posterior orientation of the stem.
Discussion: The posterior approach does generate a more uniform cement mantle. Several studies suggest that a cement mantle smaller than 2mm or greater than 10mm can be detrimental to the survivorship of the arthroplasty. This study suggests that a deficient cement mantle is more likely using an anterolateral approach.
Correspondence should be addressed to Dr Carlos Wigderowitz, Honorary Secretary of BORS, Division of Surgery & Oncology, Section of Orthopaedic & Trauma Surgery, Ninewells Hospital & Medical School Tort Centre, Dundee, DD1 9SY.
