Abstract
Purpose Of The Study: Avulsion fractures of the anterior tibial spine are uncommon injury and we have evaluated the results in-patients who have undergone arthrotomy and fixation of the fracture.
Material & Method: Twenty five patients were followed up between 21–108 months (mean 44 months) after the operation. They were evaluated clinically, radiologically and the residual ACL laxity was measured with KT 1000. Lysholm scoring scale has been used to assess the outcome.
Eight fractures were fixed with a single AO screw; 5 with Herbert screws; 4 with a steel wire loop and 8 with absorbable stitch.
Results: Significant residual anterior laxity despite adequate fracture union was a common finding. The ACL laxity was maximum in adults in whom absorbable stitch had been used to fix the fracture and they had a corresponding lower Lysholm score.
In 2 out of the 5 patients where Herbert screws had been used there was significant migration of the screws.
Additional articular damage was observed in 3 patients who were pedestrians hit by a car. All 3 ended up with restricted knee movements and poor results. Three individuals who had their knee immobilised in 250–500 of flexion developed flexion deformities, which took 12–18 months to recover.
Conclusions: We recommend that use of absorbable stitches as a method of fixation be avoided in adults. Herbert screws in this situation have a tendency to migrate. AO screws or a non-absorbable loop should be used were possible. Immobilisation of the knee in excessive flexion leads to prolonged flexion deformity and we recommend immobilising the knee in no more than 100 of flexion.
Honorary Secretary Mr Bimal Singh. Correspondence should be addressed to BOSA (British Orthopaedic Specialists Association), c/o Royal College of Surgeons, 35 – 43 Lincoln’s Inn Fields, London WC2A 3PE.
